Best Tempur-Pedic Mattress Alternatives
- Best Tempur-Pedic Alternative Overall: Amerisleep AS3
- Best Tempur-Pedic Alternative for Athletes: Zoma Mattress
- Best Budget Tempur-Pedic Alternative: Vaya Mattress
- Best Natural Tempur-Pedic Alternative: Nolah Natural 11
- Best Customizable Tempur-Pedic Alternative: Saatva Solaire
- Best Soft Tempur-Pedic Alternative: Amerisleep AS5
- Best Cooling Tempur-Pedic Alternative: Bear Elite Hybrid
- Best Luxury Tempur-Pedic Alternative Helix Midnight Luxe
- Best Hybrid Tempur-Pedic Alternative: Purple Hybrid Premier 4
For a long time, the Tempur-Pedic mattress brand cornered the mattress market. It was simply the best, and no other mattresses could compete with it. So you basically had to pay the Tempur-Pedic premium if you wanted a high-quality hybrid or memory foam mattress.
Now, times have changed. There are lots of mattresses on the market that can compete with Tempur-Pedic mattresses in terms of quality and comfort. Many of these mattresses even have the edge over this classic mattress brand.
Not to mention that most of them cost less than a comparable Tempur-Pedic mattress. Let’s take a look at the cream of the crop of Tempur-Pedic alternatives.
Amerisleep AS3 Overview
Those who want a Tempur-Pedic mattress alternative that has a little bit of everything should check out the AS3 by Amerisleep. This medium mattress offers tons of versatility, cooling, allergy relief, and bounce – all at a great price.
- Eco-Friendly Cushion
Plant-based memory foam is more responsive and breathable than traditional memory foam.
- Temperature-Neutral Surface
Cooling cover keeps the sleep surface cool to the touch.
- Supportive and Sturdy Core
Durable base foam means you won’t be replacing this mattress for decades to come.
The AS3’s fantastic feel is all thanks to its Bio-Pur® foam. This plant-based memory foam fixes a lot of traditional memory foam’s inherent issues. This gives it a bouncy and cool feel that’s superior to most other memory foam mattresses.
Where traditional memory foam retains heat, Bio-Pur® foam sheds it. Where traditional memory foam takes forever to respond, Bio-Pur® foam bounces right back. Where traditional memory foam can experience problems with moisture buildup and allergens, Bio-Pur® foam is breathable and fights microbes and moisture alike.
The comfort layer of the AS3 is composed of Amerisleep’s cooling and responsive Bio-Pur® foam. Right underneath this plant-based memory foam sits the HIVE® transition layer. This layer offers targeted support to each body area, giving more lift to your middle and more compression under your joints.
On the bottom, the Bio-Core® base foam offers tons of lift and support. It keeps you from sinking into the sleeping surface and also means the AS3 will avoid sagging and soft spot development for a full two decades – as evidenced by its generous 20-year warranty.
All this comfort is wrapped up in the Refresh Cover. This cover uses minerals to convert body heat into far infrared energy, keeping you cool as a cucumber all night.
SEE ALSO: Amerisleep Mattress Reviews
Zoma Mattress Overview
If you want the best Tempur-Pedic mattress alternative for those with active lifestyles, say hello to the Zoma Mattress! This mattress was designed by and for athletes. So it’s perfect for those who need to recover from a long day of training or physical work.
- Buoyant and Responsive Surface
Reactiv™ transition layer ensures the comfort layer never experiences slow response time or body impressions.
- Cooling Comfort Materials
AirCloth cover and gel memory foam work in sync to regulate temperature.
- Durable and Sag-Free Base Foam
Support+ foam ensures the Zoma will last at least a decade.
The Zoma is slightly on the firmer side of medium. So it retains the versatility of a medium mattress while offering much of the support of a medium-firm mattress. This makes it perfect for back sleepers and those who suffer from back pain, especially back pain caused by physical exertion.
Another thing you’ll notice about lying down on this mattress is how responsive it is. It can bounce back underneath you and resist body impressions better than most memory foam mattresses. This is thanks to the Zoma’s Reactiv™ layer, which we’ll talk more about below.
The Zoma starts off with an airy, breathable cover that works with its thermally conductive and equally breathable gel memory foam comfort layer to push hot air out and pull cool air in, keeping the mattress’s temperature regulated all night.
Next up, the Reactiv™ layer provides the bounce in this bed. It fights body impressions and ensures the comfort layer springs back into place. This makes the Zoma perfect for those who are as active while they sleep as they are when awake.
Finally, the Support+ layer provides durable and sturdy support to the upper layers, ensuring the Zoma lasts through every day of its 10-year warranty.
Vaya Mattress Overview
Perhaps the best Tempur-Pedic mattress alternative for the price is the Vaya Mattress. This mattress features a simple design that allows it to offer fantastic quality and comfort at an even more fantastic price.
- Minimal and Budget-Friendly Design
Simple design allows Vaya to offer a great price without sacrificing quality.
- Airy Cover and Comfort Foam
Open-cell foam and breathable cover regulate temperature throughout the night.
- High-Valuable, Durable Core Foam
Ultra-dense base foam ensures this mattress lasts as long as its more expensive competitors.
The Vaya is medium to medium-plush, so it’s got enough support for combo sleepers, but it’s also got more than enough pressure relief to keep side sleepers happy. The highly contouring foam also cushions pressure points to relieve pain.
The Vaya Mattress features a simple, two-layer construction. The first layer is the memory foam comfort layer. This Vaya Comfort Foam is some of the most highly contouring memory foam on the market. It can follow the curve of your body to relieve pressure and keep your spine aligned.
The open-cell foam also works with the ultra-breathable and plush cover to keep you cool and sweat-free all night.
The bottom layer is composed of Vaya Base Foam. This layer is the one that fights sinkage so that you never have that “stuck” feeling from sinking into your mattress. This layer also fights the signs of aging in your mattress for at least ten years. That’s right! Despite its fantastic price tag, the Vaya Mattress comes with an equally fantastic 10-year warranty.
Nolah Natural 11 Overview
If the best Tempur-Pedic mattress alternative for you is an all-natural mattress, take a look at the Nolah Natural 11. This latex hybrid mattress offers the spring of latex and the bounce of coils. It’s the closest you can get to the feel of an innerspring – without all the problems that come with this dated mattress type.
- Breathable Cotton & Wool
Organic textiles offer all-natural breathability and fire protection.
- Motion-Isolating Pocketed Coils
Supportive coils provide a bouncy and buoyant sleep surface.
- Contouring & Cool Latex
Natural Talalay latex is springy and breathable without the need for synthetic infusions.
The first thing you will notice about the Natural is its bounce. It combines springy latex with bouncy coils to create an ultra-responsive mattress. Unlike innerspring mattresses, however, this hybrid has tons of motion transfer control to ensure the bed only bounces back underneath you without sending motion all over the sleep surface.
The first layer of the Natural is an organic cotton cover combined with an organic wool under-layer. These layers provide breathability and moisture control. And the organic wool layer also offers a natural fire barrier that’s free of harsh chemicals.
Next up, you’ll find a comfort layer of highly contouring Talalay latex. Talalay latex is the closest alternative to memory foam. It’s almost as contouring, and much springier and more breathable for a cooler and more responsive feel.
Underneath the Talalay comfort layer, you’ll find a deep and supportive Talalay transition layer. This firmer and denser foam offers lots of buoyancy, and it also protects you from pressure exerted by the coils below.
This hybrid’s support core is made up of HDMaxTM coils that offer 25 percent more support than traditional coil systems. They’re also arranged into three zones that target each body area with the right pressure relief and support for its needs.
Saatva Solaire Overview
If you want a highly customizable Tempur-Pedic alternative, consider the Saatva Solaire. This mattress allows you to choose from 50 precise firmness settings. You can even choose a firmness for each side on the queen or above.
- Easily Changeable Feel
Adjustable firmness lets you change your bed’s feel at the touch of a button.
- Protective Policies
Lifetime warranty means this bed will last a whole lot longer than the average.
- Cooling Comfort Foams
Combination of gel memory foam and natural latex foam provides cooling pressure relief.
The Solaire doesn’t really have a firmness level because you can choose virtually any firmness level you want. This makes it a perfect mattress for all sleep positions, especially for those who like to change their firmness based on their mood.
That’s not to say you can’t expect a consistent feel from the Solaire. No matter what firmness you select, this mattress will still be cooling and responsive, thanks to its combination of gel-infused memory foam and natural latex layers.
The Solaire starts off with a plush and breathable three-inch Euro top treated with botanical antimicrobial compounds that inhibit microbial growth.
Underneath the Euro-top, you’ll find an upper comfort layer of buoyant and responsive natural latex and a lower comfort layer of cooling gel memory foam. These layers work together to create a cooling and contouring sleep surface.
Next up, a moisture barrier protects the internal mechanical components of the mattress from water damage.
The next layer is where the magic happens in this mattress. The support core features no-sink vulcanized air chambers that maintain even firmness from edge to edge and can alter their firmness at the touch of a button. So you can have a softer or firmer mattress in seconds.
Don’t let the air-chambered support core fool you, though. The Solaire is much more durable than your average air mattress. That’s why it features a lifetime warranty!
Amerisleep AS5 Overview
Those who want a soft alternative to Tempur-Pedic mattresses should check out another Amerisleep offering: the Amerisleep AS5. This mattress sports all the excellent benefits of the AS3 but offers a soft feel for those who need it.
- Plush Feel Hugs the Body
Soft feel of this mattress offers loads of pressure relief to protect sensitive pressure points.
- Soft Yet Supportive
Active Flex and Bio-Core® layers fight sinkage in this soft mattress.
- Durable and Responsive Cushion
Expect a 20-year lifespan for this mattress despite its soft feel.
Lying down on the AS5, you’ll notice right away that it offers more cradling than just about any other mattress you’ve ever experienced. This mattress is much too soft for back and stomach sleepers. It was designed with petite sleepers and side sleepers in mind, so it provides tons of pressure relief.
This isn’t to say the AS5 doesn’t provide support. It still features Amerisleep’s ultra-dense base foam. So you can expect to stay on top of the sleeping surface without sinking too deep.
The AS5 still sports a comfort layer of Amerisleep’s proprietary plant-based memory foam. This cooling memory foam is perfect for a soft mattress because it breathes and prevents overheating even as the mattress hugs your body.
This soft mattress also features the five-zoned HIVE® transition layer for targeted support. However, between the comfort layer and HIVE® layer rests a layer of Active Flex material. This buoyant material adds lots of softness without sacrificing support. It also bounces back in seconds after you switch positions.
The AS5 also has a support core of Bio-Core® foam that lasts for decades. Expect to get the same 20-year lifetime from this mattress as you would the firmer AS3.
Bear Elite Hybrid Overview
Those looking for cooling Tempur-Pedic mattress alternatives should consider the Bear Elite Hybrid. This hybrid is a fantastic choice for hot sleepers and those who love the feel of an innerspring mattress alike because of its unique construction.
- Cooling Copper Infusions
Copper memory foam fights heat and microbe buildup alike
- Adaptable Wrapped Coils
Pocketed coils can adapt to your shape and isolate motion
- Soft Pillowtop Surface
Quilted cover offers the look and feel of a classic innerspring mattress
The Elite features two layers of comfort foam atop a layer of pocketed coils for maximum bounce. It also sports a hand-quilted and cushioned cover with buttons. The buttoned cover is what gives the Elite its innerspring look and feel.
The Elite might bounce underneath you like an innerspring mattress, but it’s far superior when it comes to contouring and motion transfer control. The pocketed coils can adapt to your shape because they move independently. This independent movement is also why they can bounce without sending waves of motion all over the bed.
The cushioned cover starts off the Elite mattress. It combines PCM and Celliant fabrics to create an extremely cool and moisture-wicking cover that stays that way all night.
Next up, you’ll find a layer of copper-infused memory foam. Copper memory foam not only fights overheating; it also fights microbes that can trigger allergy symptoms. Below the copper foam, a layer of cut-out comfort foam offers enhanced pressure relief and air circulation.
Below the two layers of foam, you’ll find the pocketed coil support layer. This layer offers edge-to-edge support so that you can remain lifted no matter where you sleep or sit on your mattress.
Helix Midnight Luxe Overview
Those who want a luxury experience like that offered by Tempur-Pedic mattresses without the Tempur-Pedic price tag should check out the Helix Midnight Luxe. This coil and memory foam mattress offers fantastic luxury.
- Weightless Luxury Feel
Luxury foam layers give the feeling of sleeping on a cloud.
- Responsive Pocketed Coils
Adaptable coils offer customized support that fits your body.
- Temperature-Neutral Surface
Cooling cover ensures you stay sweat-free all night.
The Midnight Luxe is a hybrid mattress, so it does offer lots of responsiveness and bounce. But the first thing you’re likely to notice about the Midnight Luxe is its cloud-like feel. The layers of foam in this mattress offer a pressure-free, weightless experience that you don’t see in many mattresses – even hybrid ones.
The Midnight Luxe starts off with your choice of premium cooling cover. You can pick between a highly breathable TENCEL™ cover or a thermoconductive GlacioTex cover that draws heat away from your body.
Next up, you’ll find a layer of copper gel memory foam that fights heat and microbe buildup. The high-density comfort foam is soft and buoyant at the same time to offer you that cloud-like feel.
The next two layers of foam increase the buoyancy even further. The Memory Plus foam is designed to cushion without allowing sinkage. And the high-grade polyfoam underneath provides seamless progression to the coils below.
Bringing up the bottom, a layer of pocketed coils provides adaptable support. These coils are reinforced around the edges and in the middle for enhanced lumbar and edge support.
Purple Hybrid Premier 4 Overview
Another fantastic softer mattress, the Purple Hybrid Premier 4 puts Purple’s unique spin on the classic hybrid design. The result is an ultra-cooling and responsive hybrid mattress that has pressure relief and support in all the right places.
- Flexible, Cooling Purple Grid
Purple Grid is responsive, temperature-neutral, and pressure-relieving.
- Soft Mattress Cover Fabric
StretchMax cover provides a plush feel that doesn’t interfere with the Grid.
- Supportive Wrapped Coils
Pocketed coils offer adaptable support.
Lying down on the Premier 4, you’ll notice right away this is a softer hybrid than most. The layers of foam and hyperelastic polymer provide the cushion for this mattress, making it a great alternative to memory foam for those who want more bounce.
You’ll also notice the unique feel of the Purple Grid when you lie on this mattress. The Purple Grid is made of a flexible gel polymer that’s temperature-neutral and full of air channels that wick away heat and moisture.
The Premier 4 starts off with the premium StretchMax cover that offers a plush feel without detracting from the benefits of the Grid. Next comes the Grid itself.
The Purple Grid is about 80 percent air, meaning it stays cool and dry all night. It’s also super-responsive. The hyperelastic gel polymer can bounce right back underneath your body when you change position.
Next, a layer of transition foam helps provide buoyancy and protects your body from the coils below. The pocketed coil support layer offers lots of lift to counteract the thick, plush foam and grid above. So you can rest assured you won’t sink into this mattress even as it relieves your pressure points.
How To Choose The Right Tempur-Pedic Mattress Alternative
Choosing one of the best mattresses as an alternative to Tempur-Pedic mattresses doesn’t have to be a hassle. You just need a solid understanding of your sleep needs and how to meet them.
Mattress firmness level is measured on a scale of one to 10, with 10 being the firmest. You will normally find mattresses that range from three to eight on the scale, as anything softer or firmer is not a comfortable sleeping surface.
Your sleep position is the main thing that dictates the firmness level you need. While your body type does have some impact, the way you prefer to sleep is what decides your baseline firmness needs.
Side sleepers need the softest mattresses. When you sleep on your side, the weight of your body presses down on your joints, which can cause pain. Soft to medium mattresses (three to five on the firmness scale) absorb pressure to keep you pain-free.
Our guide on mattresses for side sleepers discusses more of what’s needed for a good night’s sleep.
Stomach sleepers, conversely, need the firmest mattresses. When you sleep on your stomach, your pelvis sinks down into the bed. This overarches the back and causes pain in the lumbar region. Firm and extra firm mattresses (sevens and eights, respectively) help keep stomach sleepers’ pelvises lifted and their spines aligned.
See also our guide to mattresses for stomach sleepers.
On the flip side (literally), back sleepers need medium-firm mattresses (six). Sleeping on your back means you need a combination of support to keep you lifted onto the sleep surface and contouring to compress under the buttocks to keep your spine aligned.
Anyone interested may want to consult our guide to mattresses for back sleepers.
Combo sleepers need middle-of-the-road firmness. When you change sleep position from night to night, you need a medium mattress (five to six) to give you enough versatility to be comfortable in all sleep positions. A mattress for combination sleeping also benefits from having a responsive feel to enable easy movement.
Your body type may not dictate your firmness baseline, but it may mean you need to go up or down based on your weight. For example, stomach sleepers typically need firm mattresses, but heavier stomach sleepers may need extra-firm ones, while lighter stomach sleepers may need medium-firm mattresses.
Average Weight Sleepers
Sleepers who weigh between 130 and 230 pounds are considered average weight. If you fall into this category, you can purchase the firmness level that corresponds to your preferred sleeping position – medium-firm for back sleepers, soft for side sleepers, and so on.
If you are over 230 pounds, you fall into the “plus-size sleepers” category. Heavier sleepers may need to go up a firmness level to get the support they need because heavier bodies exert more pressure on the mattress and may compress it more than intended. So heavier back sleepers, for example, would need a firm rather than a medium-firm mattress.
Our guide to mattresses for heavy sleepers discusses some of the top options on the market.
Petite sleepers fall under the minimum average weight of 130 pounds. If you weigh less than this, your body exerts insufficient pressure on the bed to give you enough compression. This means if you don’t go down a firmness level, your bed may not contour and relieve pressure correctly. That means whatever firmness corresponds to your sleeping position, go one softer in a mattress for lightweight sleepers.
Material and Construction
Aside from firmness, the material your Tempur-Pedic alternative is made of has the most impact on its feel. It dictates everything from responsiveness to temperature regulation to motion isolation to price.
Memory foam mattresses are among the most popular choices for Tempur-Pedic alternatives because Tempur-Pedic uses memory foam so much in its lineup, and with good reason. Memory foam mattresses make for an amazing sleep experience.
A memory foam mattress is highly contouring, decently durable, and usually very affordable. That makes this type of flexible polyurethane foam among the most popular bedding materials on the market today.
The only real issues with memory foam are its responsiveness and temperature regulating ability. Memory foam tends to have a slow response time unless it has a transition or support layer of bouncy foam underneath. Memory foam also tends to retain heat unless it has infusions or breathable construction. So hot and active sleepers, beware.
Our memory foam mattress buying guide discusses this in greater depth.
A natural latex foam mattress is a good alternative to a memory foam mattress for sleepers who get hot or love to toss and turn at night. Natural latex foam is highly breathable, so it wicks away heat and moisture. It’s also delightfully springy, so it bounces back underneath your body in a way memory foam just can’t.
This means if you want an all-foam mattress with tons of airflow and a bit of spring in its step, you should spring for a latex foam mattress. See our latex vs memory foam mattress guide for an in-depth, side-by-side comparison.
The main issues with natural latex are its weight and its expense. Latex weighs a lot. So if you move often or have an adjustable base with a limited max weight capacity, this could be an issue for you. Latex is also quite expensive upfront, though its extreme durability offsets its initial cost in the long run.
Interested shoppers may want to read through our latex mattress buying guide.
Of all the mattresses you can get in lieu of a Tempur-Pedic, innerspring mattresses are not the best. They have lots of bounce and breathability, thanks to their open coil support layers. But along with that bounce and breathability comes a host of issues.
Motion transfer is a huge problem with innerspring mattresses. Open coils are wired together from one edge of the bed to the other. This means motion isolation is not their strong suit. They tend to send motion all over the bed every time you change positions.
Innerspring mattresses also have issues with durability and adaptability. Open coils wear out very fast, and they also tend to sag under your weight rather than adapt to your shape. For all these reasons, we recommend a hybrid mattress if you want coils.
Hybrid mattresses feature thick foam layers on top of pocketed coil support cores to create a pressure-relieving mattress that can contour like foam. Individually wrapped pocket coils can move independently of each other. This means that hybrids are much better than innerspring mattresses at motion isolation, edge support, and adaptability.
Hybrid mattresses make wonderful alternatives to pure latex for people who want lots of bounce without the price tag or allergy-triggering potential of latex. You can get a solid memory foam hybrid for a fraction of the cost of a latex bed and still enjoy a hypoallergenic mattress. Of course, if you want both latex and coils, a latex hybrid may be up your alley.
The main issues with hybrid mattresses are their decreased durability and cost. Hybrid mattresses are more affordable than pure latex but less affordable than pure memory foam. And the decreased durability of their coil support cores means you’ll have to replace them more often than most all-foam mattresses.
If you want to learn more, feel free to browse our hybrid mattress buying guide.
What is an acceptable sleep trial period for Tempur-Pedic mattress alternatives?
A sleep trial offers you the ability to really get to know how your mattress feels when you sleep on it. The 100-night sleep trial has become an industry standard of sorts, as it takes at least 90 nights to break in your mattress and understand how it will really feel.
For this reason, you’ll want a sleep trial that’s no less than 90 nights. Though a 100-night sleep trial or more is best.
How much can I expect to pay for a Tempur-Pedic alternative?
The price you pay for a mattress can vary wildly based on size, materials, and brand. Expect to pay no less than $400 for a quality mattress in a smaller size. Luxury mattresses in larger sizes can easily run into the thousands. For a quality queen size mattress, you should plan to spend between $600 and $2,000, depending on what material you choose.
What is the best Tempur-Pedic alternative for side sleepers?
The best Tempur-Pedic alternative for side sleepers is going to be one of the softer alternatives. If you want a pure memory foam mattress, we’d recommend the AS5 by Amerisleep as the top choice for side sleepers. Those who want a hybrid mattress should consider the Purple Premier 4, although the Amerisleep AS5 has a hybrid option that’s worth considering, as well.
How can I save money on a Tempur-Pedic alternative?
The best way to save money on mattresses of any kind is to hit the sales and target the best times of year to get older models. Sales run all year long and typically fall around major off days and long weekends, like Labor Day, Memorial Day, and the like.
The best times of year to shop for a mattress are winter and spring. These are the times when mattress sellers are getting lots of returns and are looking to get rid of older inventory to make room for the new models that arrive in summer.
What is the best Tempur-Pedic alternative for hot sleepers?
The best Tempur-Pedic alternatives for hot sleepers are the Bear Elite Hybrid and the Nolah Natural 11. The Elite regulates its temperature with a combination of pocketed coils and copper gel memory foam. Meanwhile, the Natural keeps you cool using breathable coils and even more breathable latex. Either one of these would be a fantastic solution for hot sleepers.
It used to be that if you wanted an excellent memory foam or hybrid mattress, you had to go with a Tempur-Pedic. However, nowadays, Tempur-Pedic has some stiff competition. With all the amazing Tempur-Pedic alternatives on the market now, you’re sure to find an option that works for you at a fraction of the cost of a Tempur-Pedic!
Leave a Reply