We may receive financial compensation for products purchased through links on this website. sleepjunkie.com is owned by Healthy Sleep, LLC and includes Amerisleep, LLC advertising. Learn more.

Down vs Gel Pillow: Which is the Better Choice for a Good Night’s Sleep?

Bedding Guides
Read Time: 10 minutes

  • Your choice of pillow can have a significant impact on the quality of your sleep.
  • Down pillows are made from the soft feathers of ducks and geese, while gel pillows are made from a combination of polyester and gel fibers.
  • When choosing between down and gel pillows, it’s important to consider factors such as sleep position, comfort, health, and hygiene.

When it comes to getting a good night’s sleep, the type of pillow you use can make all the difference. Two of the most popular pillow types are down pillows and gel pillows. Down pillows are made from the soft, fluffy feathers found underneath the tougher exterior feathers of ducks and geese. Gel pillows, on the other hand, are made from a combination of polyester and gel fibers. In this article, we’ll look closer at down vs. gel pillows to help you determine which one is right for you.

Understanding Pillow Types Before we dive into the differences between down and gel pillows, let’s take a moment to understand the different types of pillows available. In addition to down and gel pillows, there are also memory foam pillows, buckwheat pillows, and many other types. Each type of pillow has its own unique characteristics and benefits, so it’s important to choose the one that best suits your needs. For the purposes of this article, we’ll focus specifically on down and gel pillows, as they are two of the most popular and widely available options on the market.

Understanding Pillow Types

When it comes to purchasing a pillow, there are several different types to choose from. Each type has its own unique characteristics, materials, and benefits. Understanding the differences between the various types of pillows can help you make a well-informed decision and choose the right pillow for your needs.

Down Pillows

Down pillows are made from geese or ducks’ soft, fluffy undercoating. They are known for their softness, lightness, and warmth. Down pillows are often preferred by people who like a soft, plush pillow that can be molded to their liking. They provide excellent insulation and are ideal for cooler climates. However, they may not be suitable for people with allergies or asthma, as down can trigger respiratory problems.

Gel Pillows

Gel pillows are a relatively new type of pillow that has gained popularity in recent years. They are made from a combination of gel and memory foam, which gives them a unique feel and texture. Gel pillows are celebrated for their cooling abilities, with the gel aiding in heat dissipation to ensure a cool sleeping experience. Down and latex pillows offer hypoallergenic qualities and resilience against dust mites and allergens, catering well to individuals with allergies or asthma.

See Also: Memory Foam vs Gel Pillow

Memory Foam Pillows

Memory foam pillows are crafted from a special type of foam that conforms to the contours of your neck and head, offering personalized support and comfort. Renowned for their capacity to alleviate neck and shoulder discomfort, these pillows also boast hypoallergenic properties and resistance to dust mites and other allergens, making them an ideal option for those with allergies or asthma. However, they may not be suitable for people who prefer a soft, plush pillow.

Alternative Pillow Fillings

Alternative pillow fillings are made from materials other than down, such as polyester, microfiber, or latex. They are often less expensive than down pillows and are available in various firmness levels and densities. Alternative pillows share the hypoallergenic trait and resistance to dust mites and allergens, making them fit for those with allergies or asthma. However, they may not provide the same level of warmth and softness as down pillows.

Benefits of Down Pillows

Down pillows have been a popular choice for comfortable sleep for many years. They are made from the fluffy feathers found on the underside of geese and ducks. Here are some of the benefits of using natural down pillows:

Natural Materials and Comfort

Down pillows are made from natural materials, which means they are hypoallergenic and do not contain any synthetic fibers that can cause skin irritation or allergies. They are also soft and comfortable, making them an excellent choice for people who prefer a softer pillow.

Insulation and Fluffiness

The fluffy feathers in a down pillow provide excellent insulation, which means they can keep you warm during the colder months. They are also incredibly fluffy, which means they can be molded to fit your head and neck, providing excellent support and comfort.

Overall, natural down pillows are an excellent choice for anyone seeking a supportive and comfortable pillow. They are made from natural materials, which means they are hypoallergenic and do not contain any synthetic fibers that can lead to skin irritation or allergies. They are also incredibly fluffy and provide excellent insulation, making them the best choice for colder months.

See Also: Down vs Buckwheat Pillow

Advantages of Gel and Memory Foam Pillows

Gel and memory foam pillows have become increasingly popular in recent years, and for good reason. They offer various advantages that traditional down pillows simply can’t match. Here are some of the advantages of using a gel or memory foam pillow:

Support and Pressure Relief

One of the main advantages of gel and memory foam pillows is the support they provide. These pillows are designed to contour to the shape of your head and neck, which can help alleviate pressure points and reduce pain. Memory foam pillows, in particular, are known for their ability to provide excellent support. They can help keep your spine in alignment, which can decrease the risk of developing back and neck pain.

Cooling Properties

Another advantage of gel and memory foam pillows is their cooling properties. Many people find that traditional down pillows can trap heat and make them feel uncomfortably warm while they sleep. Gel and memory foam pillows, on the other hand, are designed to stay cool throughout the night. This can aid in achieving a more comfortable sleep and waking up feeling refreshed.

Hypoallergenic Benefits

Finally, gel and memory foam pillows offer hypoallergenic benefits that down pillows simply can’t match. Down pillows are made from feathers, which can trigger allergies in some people. Gel and memory foam pillows, on the other hand, are made from synthetic materials that are less likely to cause allergic reactions. This makes them a great choice for anyone with allergies or asthma.

In summary, gel and memory foam pillows offer a range of advantages over traditional down pillows. They provide excellent support, stay cool overnight, and offer hypoallergenic benefits. If you’re looking for a comfortable and supportive pillow, a gel or memory foam pillow could be the perfect choice for you.

Considerations for Sleep Position and Comfort

When choosing between a down pillow and a gel pillow, one of the most important considerations is sleep position. Various sleep positions demand varying levels of support and comfort to ensure a restful night’s sleep.

Side Sleepers

For those who sleep on their side, selecting a pillow that provides sufficient support for the neck and spine is crucial. A pillow that is overly thin or too soft may cause the head to sink excessively, resulting in improper spinal alignment and the risk of neck discomfort. A firmer pillow, such as a gel pillow, can help keep the head and neck in alignment while still providing the necessary comfort.

Back Sleepers

Back sleepers require a pillow that maintains the natural curve of the neck and spine. If the pillow is excessively thick or firm, it may push the head forward, causing strain on the neck and shoulders. A down pillow, which is typically softer and more malleable, can provide the necessary support while still allowing the head to sink into the pillow comfortably.

Stomach Sleepers

Stomach sleepers require the least amount of pillow support, as too much support can lead to strain on the neck and spine. A thin, soft pillow, such as a down pillow, can provide the necessary comfort without causing strain on the neck and shoulders.

Regardless of sleep position, it is important to select a pillow that offers adequate support for the neck and spine. This can help avoid pain and discomfort and ensure a good night’s sleep.

Health and Hygiene Factors

Down and gel pillows offer different benefits in terms of health and hygiene factors. Let’s break down each:

Dust Mites and Allergens

One of the biggest concerns when it comes to pillows is the presence of dust mites and allergens. Both down and gel pillows can harbor these microscopic creatures, which can cause allergic reactions in some people. However, down pillows tend to be more prone to dust mites and allergens due to their natural filling. Gel pillows, on the other hand, are made from synthetic materials that are less likely to attract these pests.

To further protect against dust mites and allergens, a pillow protector is recommended. A pillow protector is a removable cover that goes over the pillow and acts as a barrier between the sleeper and the pillow. Some pillow protectors even come with a waterproof outer coating to prevent moisture from getting into the pillow and creating a breeding ground for dust mites.

Pillow Protectors and Maintenance

In addition to protecting against dust mites and allergens, pillow protectors can also extend the life of the pillow by keeping it clean. It is recommended to wash pillow protectors every two to four weeks, depending on how often the pillow is used. This will aid to remove any dust mites, allergens, and other debris that may have accumulated on the surface of the protector.

When it comes to maintaining the pillow itself, both down and gel pillows require some level of care to keep them in good condition. Down pillows should be fluffed daily to maintain their loft and prevent clumping. They should also be washed every six months to a year, depending on how often they are used. Gel pillows, on the other hand, can be washed more frequently, usually every three to six months, depending on usage. It is important to follow the manufacturer’s instructions when washing either type of pillow to avoid damaging the filling or cover.

Both down and gel pillows can be a good choice for overall health and hygiene if they are properly maintained and protected with a pillow protector. A healthy lifestyle, which includes a balanced diet and regular exercise, can also help reduce the likelihood of allergic reactions and other health issues associated with pillows.

Selecting the Right Pillow

Choosing the right pillow can be a diffitask, but it is essential for a good night’s sleep. The right pillow can aid alleviate neck pain, provide support to your spine, and promote comfortable sleep. Here are some factors to consider when selecting the right pillow.

Firmness and Fill Power

Pillows come in various firmness levels, ranging from soft to firm. A firmer pillow provides more support, while a softer pillow enables your head to sink in. The firmness level you choose depends on your personal preferences and sleeping position. For instance, side sleepers may prefer a firmer pillow to keep their neck and head aligned, while stomach sleepers may prefer a softer pillow to prevent neck strain.

Fill power refers to the amount of filling in a pillow. A higher fill power indicates a higher quality and longer-lasting pillow. Down pillows have a high fill power and are known for their softness and comfort. However, down pillows may not be suitable for people with allergies or asthma. Gel pillows, on the other hand, have a lower fill power but provide a firmer surface than down pillows.

Pillow Lifespan and Quality

The lifespan of a pillow can depend on its quality and how well it is maintained. High-quality pillows can last up to three years, while low-quality pillows may need to be replaced every six months. To ensure your pillow lasts longer, invest in a pillow protector and wash your pillow regularly according to the manufacturer’s instructions.

Personal Preferences and Needs

Personal preferences and needs play a vital role in selecting the right pillow. For instance, people with allergies or asthma should opt for hypoallergenic pillows. Side sleepers may prefer a contoured pillow that provides extra support to the neck and spine. Stomach sleepers may prefer a thinner pillow to prevent neck strain.

Impact on Sleep Quality and Wellbeing

When choosing the right pillow, consider its impact on sleep quality and overall well-being. Both down and gel pillows have unique benefits and drawbacks.

Improving Sleep Quality

A better night’s sleep is essential for overall health and well-being. According to the Sleep Foundation, gel pillows are known for their cooling properties, which help regulate body temperature and prevent overheating. This can be advantageous for individuals who typically feel warm when sleeping or reside in warmer regions. On the other hand, down pillows are known for their softness and fluffiness, which can provide a comfortable sleeping surface that conforms to the head and neck.

Alleviating Pain and Discomfort

Pillows can also alleviate pain and discomfort. According to Amerisleep, memory foam pillows, often used in gel pillows, can relieve pressure by contouring the shape of the head and neck. This can be particularly advantageous for those who suffer from neck or back pain. Down pillows, on the other hand, may not provide as much support, which can be a drawback for those who need extra support for their head and neck.

Ultimately, the choice between down and gel pillows comes down to personal preference and individual needs. It’s important to consider factors such as sleep position, body temperature, and any pain or discomfort when making a decision. Regardless of the pillow type, a good night’s sleep can positively impact overall well-being.


What are the differences between gel and traditional memory foam pillows? 

Gel memory foam pillows incorporate gel particles fused with memory foam, providing a cooling effect by dissipating body heat. This makes them ideal for hot sleepers. On the other hand, traditional memory foam pillows mold to the shape of your head and neck but might retain more heat compared to their gel-infused counterparts.

How do memory foam pillows support neck and back health? 

Memory foam pillows support neck and back health by conforming to the shape of your head and neck, offering customized support. This contouring helps maintain spinal alignment, reduces pressure points, and can alleviate pain in the neck, back, and shoulders, making them ideal for individuals seeking targeted support.

What are the benefits of a shredded memory foam pillow over a solid memory foam pillow? 

Shredded memory foam pillows offer customizable comfort, as you can adjust the fill to change the loft and firmness. They typically allow for better air circulation compared to solid memory foam pillows, reducing heat retention. This adjustability and improved breathability can enhance sleep comfort for various sleep positions.

Can a gel fiber pillow help regulate body heat during sleep? 

Yes, a gel fiber pillow can assist with body heat regulation. These pillows often include gel-infused fibers or a gel layer, which helps to draw away heat from the body, keeping the sleeping surface cooler. This is particularly beneficial for people who tend to overheat during the night.

What should I consider when choosing between feather pillows and memory foam pillows? 

When choosing between feather pillows and memory foam pillows, consider factors like firmness, support, and allergy concerns. Feather pillows are typically softer and offer a traditional feel, but they might not provide the same level of support as memory foam pillows. Memory foam pillows tend to offer better contouring and support for the neck and spine. If you have allergies, memory foam mattresses and pillows are usually hypoallergenic, while feather pillows might trigger allergies.


Selecting the right pillow is crucial for enhancing sleep quality and overall wellbeing. Whether you opt for a gel memory foam pillow, shredded memory foam pillow, or a traditional memory foam or feather pillow, understanding their unique properties is key. Gel-infused options provide cooling effects and regulate body heat, while memory foam offers contouring support, which is beneficial for spinal alignment and reducing pressure points. Shredded memory foam pillows bring the added advantage of adjustability and breathability. Ultimately, the choice depends on personal preferences, sleep habits, and health considerations. Remember, a well-chosen pillow contributes to a restful night and significantly affects your long-term neck and spinal health.

Christine Lapp is a full-time graduate student and part-time freelancer for Sleep Junkie. Since she was a little girl on the soccer field, Christine has had a love for sports, and she believes everybody should get up and get moving once a day. Now, she incorporates her love for exercise into her studies, pursuing a degree in exercise physiology. Christine understands that what you do during your waking hours has a direct impact on your night’s sleep. In our better sleep guides, she offers advice for developing healthy daytime habits to nurture a more peaceful slumber.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *