We may receive financial compensation for products purchased through links on this website. sleepjunkie.com is owned by Healthy Sleep, LLC and includes Amerisleep, LLC advertising. Learn more.

10-Inch vs 12-Inch Mattress: Making the Right Choice for a Good Night’s Sleep

Mattress Resources
Read Time: 7 minutes

  • Key Decision Factors: The article emphasizes the importance of considering individual factors such as body type, sleeping position, and personal preferences when choosing between 10 and 12-inch mattresses.
  • Height Impact on Firmness: It succinctly explains that the primary difference in feel between a 10-inch and a 12-inch mattress lies in their height, with the former tending to be firmer and the latter offering a more plush feel.
  • Sleeping Position Recommendations: The guide provides specific recommendations for each sleeping position, catering to the diverse needs of side sleepers, back sleepers, stomach sleepers, and those who change positions frequently during the night.
  • Comprehensive Thickness Factors: The article goes beyond just thickness comparisons, delving into factors influencing mattress thickness, including body type, preferred sleeping style, mattress firmness, physical health conditions, mattress elevation, and overall height considerations.

When it comes to choosing the right mattress, the thickness plays a crucial role in determining your comfort level and quality of sleep. In this comprehensive guide, we will explore the difference between 10 and 12-inch mattresses and help you decide which one is the right fit for your lifestyle and sleeping habits.

Factors to Consider When Deciding on Mattress Thickness

Before we delve into the specifics of 10 and 12-inch mattresses, it’s essential to consider certain factors that can influence your decision-making process. These factors include your body type and weight, preferred sleeping position, and the number of sleep partners you share your bed with.

Body Type and Weight

Your body type and weight significantly determine the mattress thickness that best suits your needs. Lightweight sleepers weighing up to 130 lbs may prefer a thicker mattress that offers support and a bit of give for added comfort. On the other hand, average sleepers, weighing between 130-230 lbs, can benefit from ten- and 12-inch mattresses, depending on their preference for firmness and thickness. Heavier sleepers weighing over 230 lbs are recommended to opt for a 12-inch mattress that provides extra firmness and support.

Sleeping Position

The way you sleep also influences the ideal thickness of your mattress. Different sleeping positions require thick mattresses with varying levels of support and cushioning. Let’s explore the recommendations for each sleeping position:

  • Side sleeping: Side sleepers typically benefit from a more plush mattress that supports the curves of the shoulders and hips. A 12-inch mattress of medium firmness is often recommended for side sleepers.
  • Back sleeping: Back sleepers can sleep comfortably on 10-inch and 12-inch mattresses. However, the optimal mattress for back sleepers should have a thinner comfort layer and a thicker support layer to maintain the natural alignment of the neck and spine.
  • Stomach sleeping: Stomach sleepers should opt for mattresses with thinner comfort layers and thicker support layers to prevent neck and spinal misalignment. The ideal mattress thickness for stomach sleepers ranges from 10-11 inches, depending on the manufacturer.
  • Combination sleeping: If you tend to change your sleeping positions throughout the night, a 12-inch mattress of medium firmness is often recommended for optimal comfort and support.

Number of Sleep Partners

If you share your bed with a partner, the number of sleep partners becomes a crucial consideration. Sharing a thin mattress together with a partner puts additional pressure on the bed, and inadequate support can lead to sagging and discomfort. Thicker mattresses with better support are recommended for couples to ensure restful sleep. Additionally, thicker mattresses also offer less motion transfer, which is especially beneficial for light sleepers.

Now that we have explored the key factors to consider when choosing mattress thickness let’s dive into the specifics of 10 and 12-inch mattresses.

Understanding the Difference: 10 vs. 12-inch Mattresses

The primary difference between a 10-inch and 12-inch mattress lies in their height, which can affect the overall feel and firmness of the mattress. While a 10-inch mattress tends to be firmer, a 12-inch mattress offers a more plush feel. However, it’s important to note that the firmness of a memory foam mattress is not solely determined by the thickness but also by the materials and construction of the mattress.

Mattresses have a Firmness Scale, ranging from 1 to 10, to help you understand how soft or firm they are. Lower numbers indicate a softer mattress, while higher numbers indicate a firmer mattress. However, it’s essential to remember that the perception of comfort varies from person to person, and there is no one-size-fits-all formula for determining the ideal firmness level.

Mattress Thickness and Comfort

When it comes to mattress thickness, there is no universal standard, but the average thickness of most mattresses ranges from 8 to 14 inches. Manufacturers categorize mattresses into different thickness levels, including low profile, slim, standard, deep, thick, and extra deep mattresses. While this categorization provides a general guideline, personal preferences, and specific requirements should take precedence when choosing the right mattress thickness.

Factors to Consider When Determining Mattress Thickness

To ensure you select the ideal mattress thickness for your needs, here are some essential factors to consider:

Body Type

Your body type plays a significant role in determining the optimal mattress thickness. Heavier individuals may require thicker mattresses to provide adequate support and prevent sagging. On the other hand, lighter individuals may find thinner mattresses comfortable, but they should still ensure sufficient support for a restful sleep.

Preferred Sleeping Style

Different sleeping styles require varying levels of support and cushioning. Consider your preferred sleeping style, whether you sleep on your back, side, stomach, or a combination of positions. Back sleepers generally benefit from 10- and 12-inch mattresses, while stomach sleepers may require a thicker, firmer mattress to alleviate pressure on the spine. Side sleepers often find a softer 10-inch mattress more suitable for supporting their shoulders and hips.

Mattress Firmness

The firmness level of a mattress determines how soft or hard it feels. Choosing a mattress with the right firmness is essential to ensure optimal comfort and support. The comfort layer, typically ranging from 1.5 to 6 inches thick, primarily determines the mattress’s firmness. Thicker mattresses often offer better support and pain relief compared to thinner mattresses.

Physical Health Conditions

If you have specific physical health conditions, such as mobility issues, fibromyalgia, arthritis, back pain, or joint pain, it’s crucial to consider your mattress thickness carefully. Thicker mattresses with motion isolation qualities can be beneficial for individuals with limited mobility or chronic pain.

Mattress Elevation

Consider whether your mattress will be placed on a frame or box spring, on the floor, or on top of a bed frame, box springs, risers, or foundations. The height of your bed should be comfortable for effortlessly getting in and out of bed. A thicker mattress can provide the desired elevation if you prefer a taller bed. However, shorter individuals should ensure that the total height of the bed is suitable for their needs.


Your height can also influence your sleep position and preference for mattress thickness. Taller individuals may find a thicker mattress more comfortable, while shorter individuals may prefer a thinner mattress for ease of getting in and out of bed.

By considering these factors, you can narrow down your options and select the mattress thickness that best suits your needs and preferences.

Factors Determining Mattress Thickness

The thickness of a mattress depends on the layers inside it. Most mattresses have two main layers: the comfort and support layers. Higher-quality mattresses may feature additional transition layers for added support or cooling technologies. Let’s explore each layer of soft mattress in detail:

Comfort Layer

The comfort layer is the topmost layer of the mattress, directly in contact with your body. It provides support and comfort and ensures even body weight and distribution, pain relief, and pressure reduction. Comfort layers can be made from various materials, including:

  1. Latex foam: All-natural or synthetic rubber with a fast response time to touch.
  2. Polyurethane (PU) foam: Affordable and commonly used for mattress toppers.
  3. Memory foam: Made with PU foam, it has a slower response time to touch.
  4. Gel foam: Soft and durable, it offers better temperature regulation but is more expensive.
  5. Natural fibers: All-natural materials like latex, cotton, bamboo fibers, wool, and even horsehair.
  6. Micro/nano coils: Small coils covered by a thin layer of foam, fiber, or a quilted cover.

The thickness of the comfort layer can vary between 1.5 to 6 inches, depending on the mattress design and desired level of comfort.

Support Layer

The support layer, also known as the base layer or core of the mattress, lies beneath the comfort layer. It provides durability stability, and aids in spinal alignment. The support layer typically constitutes nearly 50% of the mattress composition in high-quality mattresses. The support layer can be made from various materials, including dense foam for foam mattresses or coils for hybrid and innerspring mattresses. The thickness of the support layer varies depending on the mattress design and the desired level of support.

Making the Right Choice: 10 vs 12-Inch mattress

Now that we have explored the factors influencing mattress thickness and the components of thin mattresses that determine it let’s consider the differences between 10 and 12-inch mattresses to help you make an informed decision.

Comfort and Firmness

The primary difference between a 10-puffy mattress and a 12-inch mattress lies in their height and resulting feel. A 10-inch mattress tends to be firmer, while a 12-inch mattress offers a more plush feel. However, it’s important to note that firmness is not solely determined by thickness but also by the materials and construction of the mattress. Therefore, it’s crucial to consider the overall design and materials used in the mattress to determine its firmness level accurately.

Personal Preference

When choosing between a 10-inch and 12-inch mattress, personal preference plays a significant role. What may be comfortable for one person may not be suitable for another. Factors such as body type, preferred sleeping position, and desired level of firmness should guide your decision. It’s recommended to test different mattresses and consult customer reviews to determine which thickness and firmness level align with your preferences.

Additional Considerations

While mattress thickness is an essential aspect to consider, it’s equally important to assess other factors, such as the quality of materials used, durability, motion isolation, and temperature regulation. These factors can significantly impact the overall comfort and lifespan of the mattress.

FAQs about 10-inch vs 12-inch mattress

Is an 8-inch Mattress Thick Enough?

An 8-inch mattress can be suitable for lightweight sleepers who prefer a firmer sleeping surface. However, it’s important to ensure that the mattress provides sufficient support and comfort for restful sleep.

Does the Base Layer Affect Mattress Durability?

Yes, the memory foam base layer of the mattress plays a crucial role in its durability. Mattresses with a firm core foam layer can typically last up to 10 years or more, depending on the quality of materials and construction.

How Thick is the Average Mattress?

The average thickness of most adult mattresses ranges from 8 to 12 inches. However, it’s essential to consider personal preferences and specific requirements when selecting the ideal mattress thickness.


Choosing the right mattress thickness is essential for a good night’s sleep. By considering factors such as body type, sleeping, preferred sleep position, and personal preferences, you can determine whether a 10- or 12-inch mattress fits you. Remember to assess the overall comfort, firmness, and quality of materials used in the mattress to ensure a restful and rejuvenating sleep experience. Take your time to research and test different options to find the perfect mattress that meets your unique needs.

Christine Lapp is a full-time graduate student and part-time freelancer for Sleep Junkie. Since she was a little girl on the soccer field, Christine has had a love for sports, and she believes everybody should get up and get moving once a day. Now, she incorporates her love for exercise into her studies, pursuing a degree in exercise physiology. Christine understands that what you do during your waking hours has a direct impact on your night’s sleep. In our better sleep guides, she offers advice for developing healthy daytime habits to nurture a more peaceful slumber.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *