Best Casper Mattress Alternatives

- Best Overall: Amerisleep AS3
- Best Luxury: Zoma Boost
- Best Budget: Vaya Hybrid
- Best For Side Sleepers: Helix Midnight Luxe
- Best Innerspring: Saatva Classic
- Best Pillow Top: Nolah Evolution 15″
- Best Latex: Organica
- Best Cooling: Amerisleep AS6 Black Series
- Best Organic: PlushBeds Signature Bliss
- Best Soft: Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid
- Best Hotel Mattress: Westin Heavenly Bed
- Best Foam: Zoma Start
The Casper lineup of mattresses offers a few quality products that can certainly offer you a good night’s sleep. However, the options Casper offers are a little sparse, and it’s quite possible they may not have a product that fits exactly what you need. If that describes your situation, keep reading our list of fantastic Casper Mattress alternatives that might just fit your needs and budget.
Best Casper Mattress Alternatives
Watch Our Amerisleep AS3 Video Review
If you’re considering a Casper mattress but want an alternative that offers more advanced materials, better pressure relief, and enhanced durability, the Amerisleep AS3 is my top pick. After researching and testing multiple mattresses, my team of testers and I found the AS3 to be one of the most well-rounded options for a wide variety of sleepers.
- With its medium feel, responsive foam layers, and cooling features, the AS3 is a true competitor to Casper, offering exceptional comfort and long-term support.
- Unlike traditional memory foam beds that can feel too firm or sink excessively, the AS3 strikes a perfect balance. Its Bio-Pur® foam provides excellent contouring without trapping heat, a major advantage over many mainstream memory foam models.
- While Casper also incorporates memory foam in its design, I found Amerisleep’s plant-based approach to be more breathable and responsive.
- During my testing, I noticed the HIVE® technology in the transition layer made a difference—it softened pressure at the shoulders and hips while reinforcing lumbar support, something Casper doesn’t integrate as effectively.
- If you share a bed, this means fewer disturbances from a partner shifting positions at night.
- Additionally, the edge support is noticeably stronger than what I’ve seen in Casper’s all-foam models, which is important if you like to sleep near the perimeter or sit on the edge of the bed.
- For those who sleep hot, the AS3 also pulls ahead. The Refresh Cooling Cover and open-cell foam design help regulate temperature better than the standard foams found in many Casper models.
Ultimately, suppose you’re drawn to the idea of a Casper mattress but want an alternative that offers better cooling, more responsive foam, and zoned pressure relief. In that case, the Amerisleep AS3 is a standout choice. It’s a fantastic all-around mattress that works well for most sleepers, whether you’re a solo sleeper or sharing the bed. Plus, with its 20-year warranty and durable construction, it’s built to last much longer than many standard bed-in-a-box options.
- 9 Value
- 8 Edge Support
- 9 Trial Period
- 9 Response Time
- 10 Motion Transfer
- 10 Cooling & Breathability
I sought to locate the finest Casper mattress substitute that matched all of the following criteria: excellent comfort, firm support, dependable durability, and actual cooling advantages rather than simply the hype. The Amerisleep AS3 was determined to be the best solution after a thorough analysis and practical testing:
- Memory foam is tricky. Get it wrong, and you either sink too much or feel stuck, which can be a dealbreaker for many sleepers. Casper mattresses use standard memory foam, but I found Amerisleep’s Bio-Pur® foam to be a clear upgrade. It’s plant-based, making it more breathable and responsive, and it adapts faster to movement. During my testing, I noticed that shifting positions on the AS3 felt effortless, whereas traditional memory foam beds—including Casper’s all-foam models—tended to feel slower to respond.
- Another reason I picked the AS3? The zoned support is just better. I analyzed how different mattresses handle pressure points, and while Casper’s support is decent, Amerisleep’s HIVE® technology takes it a step further.
- Foam mattresses tend to trap heat, and this was something I paid close attention to during testing. Casper uses open-cell foam for breathability, but I found that Amerisleep’s Bio-Pur® material and Refresh Cooling Cover did a noticeably better job at keeping me cool.
- Casper mattresses are comfortable, but edge support has never been their strongest feature—which is something I couldn’t ignore. The AS3, on the other hand, held its shape much better around the perimeter, making it easier to sit or sleep near the edge without that unstable, “roll-off” feeling.
- Motion isolation was another big factor. If you sleep with a partner, a bed that absorbs movement instead of transferring it is key. While testing the AS3, I barely noticed movement when someone else got in or out of bed—something I couldn’t say about every Casper model I tried.
Some memory foam beds can feel like quicksand, but this one had the perfect mix of softness and support. No matter how I shifted around, it adapted to me instead of making me work to get comfortable.
Cosy and Cushioned in All the Right Places
As someone who sleeps on my side a lot, I’m picky about mattresses. If a bed is too firm, my shoulders and hips start to ache. Too soft, and my back gets out of alignment.
But with the AS3, I sank in just enough to feel cushioned, while the foam still had a little bounce to keep me from sinking too deep.
It’s like the mattress knew exactly where I needed support and where I needed pressure relief—kind of impressive, honestly.
Just the Right Amount of Support
When I flipped onto my back, I could feel the support layer kicking in. My lower back stayed lifted instead of sinking, and my weight felt evenly spread out. Some softer beds make me feel like I’m curving into a hammock, but this one kept my spine nice and straight. If you like a bed that gives you a gentle, supportive lift, this one does a solid job.
Not Too Squishy, Not Too Stiff
I’m not a full-time stomach sleeper, but I tested it out for a bit. Sometimes softer mattresses make my lower back dip too much in this position, but the AS3 held up pretty well. It’s not rock-hard, but it’s not a marshmallow either—a good in-between feel that works if you switch positions a lot.
Memory foam mattresses can run hot, but the AS3 felt noticeably cool, especially with the optional Refresh cover. It wasn’t just “not hot”—it was cool to the touch.
After analyzing online reviews, the mattress users have praised the mattress such as:
- Side sleepers rave about the pressure relief, saying their shoulders and hips feel well-supported without any discomfort.
- Back sleepers appreciate the lumbar support, noting that it helps reduce back pain over time.
- Hot sleepers love the cooling effect, with multiple reviewers mentioning that it “sleeps cooler than any other memory foam mattress” they’ve tried.
- Many customers found it a great alternative to Casper, praising its balance of comfort and support while offering more breathability.
The Amerisleep AS3 is built with three high-quality foam layers, each designed for a specific purpose: pressure relief, responsiveness, and long-term durability.
- Bio-Pur® Foam (Comfort Layer)
The top layer of the AS3 is made of Amerisleep’s signature Bio-Pur® foam, which is a plant-based memory foam designed to sleep cooler and respond faster than traditional memory foam.
- Unlike standard foam that traps heat, Bio-Pur® has an open-cell structure, allowing more airflow so it doesn’t hold onto body warmth.
- It’s also more buoyant than regular memory foam, meaning you get contouring without feeling stuck—which makes it an excellent choice for combination sleepers.
- This layer provides that initial plush comfort while ensuring pressure relief for your shoulders and hips.
- HIVE® Transition Layer (Zoned Support)
Beneath the Bio-Pur® foam is the HIVE® transition layer, which is designed to provide targeted support and pressure relief in the right areas.
- This layer has a hexagonal cutout design that creates five different support zones.
- Softer under the shoulders and hips to ease pressure and reduce stiffness.
- Firmer under the lower back and legs to keep your spine aligned and prevent sagging.
- This zoning system helps balance comfort and support, making the AS3 adaptable to different sleep positions.
- Bio-Core® Support Foam (Base Layer)
At the foundation of the mattress is Bio-Core® foam, a high-density support layer that gives the AS3 its durability and structure.
- It prevents sagging over time, which is essential for long-term comfort.
- This layer ensures consistent spinal support, no matter your sleep position.
- Helps the mattress hold its shape while still allowing for a slight bounce and responsiveness.
Extra Cooling: Refresh Cover (Optional Upgrade)
Amerisleep also offers an optional Refresh Cooling Cover, which is designed to dissipate heat and improve circulation.
- Unlike traditional fabric covers, this one is designed to absorb body heat and convert it into infrared energy, which may help with muscle recovery.
- This feature is especially helpful for hot sleepers or those with aches and pains who want extra cooling benefits.
Pros:
- Not too firm, not too soft, making it a great all-around alternative to Casper.
- Cushions shoulders and hips while keeping the spine aligned.
- Adapts to movements without making you feel stuck.
- Especially with the optional Refresh cooling cover.
- Helps reduce disruptions for couples.
Cons:
- Back and stomach sleepers who prefer extra firmness may want the AS2 instead.
- Foam construction doesn’t have the same springiness as hybrid or innerspring options.
- More affordable than some premium brands but still an investment.
Lying down on the AS3 Hybrid mattress offers a balanced experience suitable for various sleeping positions. With its medium firmness, it provides proper cushioning for side sleepers, preventing excessive sinking of shoulders and hips.
Watch Our Zoma Boost Video Review
My goal while searching for the finest luxury Casper mattress substitute was to locate one that offered premium comfort without compromising support. At that point, I discovered the Zoma Boost, a hybrid mattress made with recuperation in mind.
My team of testers and I spent hours analyzing its construction, materials, and performance to see how it stacks up against a high-end Casper model.
Right away, the Zoma Boost stands out for its ultra-plush feel combined with targeted support. It uses a mix of responsive foam layers and pocketed coils, creating a balance between contouring softness and sturdy reinforcement. If you like the idea of a Casper Wave Hybrid but want a mattress that focuses more on pressure relief and deep compression support, Zoma Boost fits the bill.
What Makes It a Strong Alternative?
Luxury hybrids like the Casper Wave Hybrid are known for their zoned support, which adapts to different areas of the body. The Zoma Boost takes a similar approach but enhances it with Triangulex™ technology, a zoned foam layer that offers extra cushioning under pressure points like the shoulders and hips. My team tested this feature, and we found it especially beneficial for side sleepers—there’s just the right amount of sink to relieve tension without feeling stuck.
Breathability is another factor where this mattress excels. One of the most common complaints about all-foam Casper models is heat retention. The Zoma Boost counters this issue with its ventilated foams and airflow-promoting coils, which kept my testers cool throughout the night. If you’re looking for a luxury alternative to Casper that prioritizes temperature control, this mattress delivers.
The Feel and Performance
Lying down on the Zoma Boost, the first thing I noticed was the plush top layer. It provides a soft, cushioning feel before gradually transitioning into firmer support from the coil system. The edge support also stood out—far more reinforced than a standard Casper model, making it a great pick for couples or anyone who likes to spread out.
Motion isolation? Surprisingly good for a hybrid. My testers and I did a few motion transfer tests, and while it’s not as still as a memory foam Casper, the Zoma Boost does a great job absorbing movement. If you share a bed, you won’t feel every small shift from your partner.
- 10 Value
- 10 Edge Support
- 9 Trial Period
- 9 Response Time
- 10 Motion Transfer
- 9 Cooling & Breathability
- Zoned Support Without the Hefty Price Tag
One of the biggest draws of the Casper Wave Hybrid is its zoned support system, which targets different areas of the body for a balanced feel. But after testing the Zoma Boost, I found its Triangulex™ technology offers similar targeted relief while maintaining a plush, high-end feel. The difference? It does so without inflating the cost, making it a great alternative for sleepers who want luxury-level zoning but don’t want to overspend.
- A More Pressure-Relieving Hybrid
While some high-end Casper mattresses do a great job of balancing foam comfort with coil support, I wanted an option that offered even better pressure relief—especially for side sleepers. During testing, my team and I noticed the Zoma Boost’s foam layers sink just enough to cradle pressure points, without making you feel stuck. That’s something I don’t always experience with a Casper hybrid, where the balance sometimes leans too much toward firmness.
- More Breathable Than a Casper Foam Model
Another factor I analyzed was temperature regulation. While Casper’s hybrid models offer some cooling features, their foam-based options can trap heat. My team and I tested the Zoma Boost and found that the ventilated foams and breathable coil system allow for better airflow, making it a great pick for hot sleepers. If you’ve ever struggled with overheating on an all-foam Casper, this mattress provides a refreshing alternative.
- Solid Edge Support for More Usable Space
Edge support is often overlooked, but it can make a huge difference in how much of the mattress you get to use. Casper’s softer models tend to have weaker edges, which can cause sagging over time. The Zoma Boost, on the other hand, has reinforced edges that feel secure and stable, whether sitting or lying down. My testers and I found that this makes a big difference for couples who need extra space or anyone who sleeps near the edge of the bed.
Back Sleeping – Plush but Supportive
- I immediately felt the pillow-top cushioning my shoulders, while the zoned support kept my lower back from sinking.
- Not too soft, not too firm—just the right balance for those who like a mix of comfort and stability.
- If you prefer an extra-firm mattress, this one might feel a bit on the plush side.
Side Sleeping – Pressure Relief Where It Counts
- The Triangulex™ zoned support system made a difference here.
- I felt zero pressure on my hips and shoulders—something many hybrids fail to get right.
- Even after a full night on my side, I woke up without the usual morning stiffness.
Stomach Sleeping – Enough Support to Prevent Overarching
- The transition foam kept my hips from sinking too much, which is a common issue in plush hybrids.
- Not as firm as some Casper models, but still stable enough for stomach sleepers who don’t want to feel stuck.
Of course, I’m not the only one who tested this mattress. I dug into hundreds of real customer reviews, and here’s what people are saying:
Side sleepers rave about the pressure relief
“This is the first mattress where I don’t wake up with sore hips!”
Great for couples
“I can’t even feel my partner moving at night—a huge upgrade from our last bed.”
Cooler than expected
“I usually wake up sweaty, but this mattress sleeps much cooler than my last one.”
Might be too soft for firm-mattress lovers
“I prefer a firmer bed, and this one is definitely on the plusher side.”
Edge support is decent, but could be better
“The edges hold up fine, but I wish they were just a little firmer.”
- The first thing I noticed was the plush quilted cover.
Unlike some Casper models that lean toward a firmer feel right away, the Zoma Boost starts with a cushioned, Euro-top layer that gives it a hotel-like softness. My team and I also tested its breathability, and we found that the fabric helps prevent overheating—an important feature for hot sleepers.
- A layer of Zoma’s exclusive React+ foam, which is intended for responsiveness and contouring, lies beneath the cover.
I discovered that it conforms to the contours of the body, relieving strain on the hips and shoulders without producing the gradual sinking sensation that certain memory foams do. Although Casper’s softer versions might occasionally feel a little too soft, this layer offers a good mix of support and comfort.
- Next comes the Triangulex™ zoned support layer, which is one of the biggest reasons I picked this mattress as a Casper alternative.
This section is divided into zones, with softer foam under the shoulders for extra cushioning and firmer foam under the lower back to maintain proper spinal alignment. My team and I tested this feature, and it stood out as a key difference from traditional hybrid designs—providing just the right amount of targeted support.
- To prevent that “stuck” feeling that sometimes happens in memory foam mattresses, the Zoma Boost includes a responsive transition foam layer.
This section acts as a buffer between the plush comfort layers and the sturdy coil base, allowing for smoother movement without losing support. I found this to be particularly helpful for combination sleepers who shift positions throughout the night.
- At the foundation of the Zoma Boost is a layer of individually wrapped coils.
This is where it differs most from Casper’s all-foam options and even competes closely with its hybrid models. I tested the support across different areas of the mattress, and I noticed that:
- The coils promote airflow, keeping the mattress cooler than Casper’s all-foam beds.
- The reinforced edges prevent sagging, something Casper hybrids don’t always prioritize.
- The coils move independently, reducing motion transfer—a great perk for couples.
- At the very bottom is a high-density base foam layer.
This gives the mattress extra durability. Casper’s hybrid models use a similar base, but I found that the Zoma Boost feels more solid overall, especially around the edges.
Pros:
- Perfect balance of softness and stability
- Eases pressure on shoulders and hips
- Enhances spinal alignment in all positions
- Prevents overheating with airflow-focused layers
- Ideal for couples who toss and turn
Cons:
- Might not suit those who prefer extra support
- Costs more than budget-friendly alternatives
To date, the Zoma Boost is my favorite mattress that I’ve tested. Lying down on the Zoma Boost mattress in different sleeping positions offers varying experiences. For back sleepers, it provides good support and alignment, though some who like a super firm mattress may find it slightly soft.
Watch Our Vaya Hybrid Video Review
Finding a high-quality mattress at an affordable price isn’t easy, especially if you’re looking for a true alternative to Casper. However, after examining several low-cost options, my testers and I discovered that the Vaya Hybrid is unique in that it strikes a balance between comfort, support, and affordability—a feature that is frequently absent from less expensive models.
So, what makes it a great Casper alternative?
For starters, its hybrid design ensures a mix of responsive bounce and pressure relief—a combination Casper mattresses are known for. While some budget beds cut corners, the Vaya Hybrid maintains a well-rounded feel that suits a wide range of sleepers without the premium price tag.
What Stood Out During Testing?
- Medium Feel for Versatility – Whether you’re a side, back, or combination sleeper, this mattress adapts well to different positions. My testers found that it offers just enough softness for pressure relief while maintaining a supportive core.
- Breathable Comfort Layers – Overheating can be a big issue in foam-heavy beds, but the Vaya Hybrid avoids this problem. Its airy foam layers and coil system work together to promote airflow, keeping me cool throughout the night.
- Responsive Yet Supportive Coils – Unlike all-foam Casper models, the Vaya Hybrid uses pocketed coils for added support and motion isolation. This means couples won’t feel excessive movement when one partner shifts positions.
- Budget-Friendly Without Feeling Cheap – Affordability often comes with trade-offs, but this mattress avoids the typical pitfalls of budget models. No stiff, overly firm feel—just a well-cushioned surface with a gentle bounce.
While Casper mattresses are often a go-to for balanced comfort, the Vaya Hybrid delivers a similar feel at a fraction of the cost. After testing it across multiple sleep positions, it’s clear that this mattress isn’t just a budget-friendly pick—it’s a thoughtfully designed alternative that doesn’t compromise on comfort.
- 10 Value
- 10 Edge Support
- 9 Trial Period
- 10 Response Time
- 7 Motion Transfer
- 9 Cooling & Breathability
It offers a Similar Feel Without the Casper Price
- Casper mattresses are popular for their medium-firm, adaptable feel that works for different sleep styles. While some budget mattresses tend to be too firm or lack proper cushioning, I found that the Vaya Hybrid maintains a balanced comfort level, similar to Casper.
- It uses soft yet responsive foam that contours to the body without the deep sink-in sensation of memory foam, making it a suitable alternative for those who want a budget version of Casper’s comfort.
A Hybrid Design Without the Premium Cost
- Casper’s hybrid models offer coil support and foam comfort, but they come at a higher price. Many budget-friendly alternatives stick to all-foam constructions to cut costs, but the Vaya Hybrid stands out by incorporating a pocketed coil base.
- This design helps with motion isolation, durability, and breathability, making it one of the few budget hybrids that can compete with Casper’s performance.
Good for Hot Sleepers on a Budget
- One of the reasons people choose Casper over traditional memory foam mattresses is the cooling factor—its breathable foams prevent overheating.
- When analyzing budget alternatives, I had to make sure they wouldn’t trap heat like standard foam models.
- The Vaya Hybrid stays cool thanks to its ventilated foam layers and coil system, making it a solid alternative for hot sleepers who don’t want to spend extra for a Casper.
An Affordable Option That Doesn’t Feel Cheap
- One of the biggest concerns with budget mattresses is longevity. Many affordable options either lose support quickly or feel cheaply made.
- I researched the Vaya Hybrid’s materials and found that it uses durable, high-density foams and a sturdy coil system, which helps prevent sagging over time.
- Unlike many budget mattresses, it provides consistent support and responsiveness, similar to what you’d expect from a Casper model.
The Vaya Hybrid was unexpectedly comfy to lie down on right away. The top layer of foam felt cozy and welcoming as I got comfortable; it provided just the right amount of cushioning to relieve stress without giving me the sinking feeling that other memory foam may provide.
The ideal balance between supporting me and letting my body sink into the surface was achieved by medium firmness.
I was first struck by how perfectly the mattress fit my lower back when I was on my back, eliminating any unpleasant gaps.
The responsiveness was one of the most notable features. The buoyant coil layer made changing positions easy. The mattress is a good option for combo sleepers who move around a lot during the night because I never felt like I had to struggle to get out of it.
My spine remained in a neutral position because of the responsive lift provided by the pocketed coils that operated beneath the foam. I didn’t experience any pressure or stiffness even after lying still for a time.
I wouldn’t describe this mattress as the firmest for stomach sleeping, but the coil structure did a nice job of keeping my hips from dropping too far. However, compared to an all-foam option, it is still more supportive.
As I rolled onto my side, I could feel the foam conforming to my body’s natural curves, particularly those of my hips and shoulders.
Customer Feedback
Many sleepers have shared positive experiences with the Vaya Hybrid, highlighting its comfort, support, and value. Here’s what some real customers had to say:
- Couples also appreciate how well the mattress minimizes motion transfer:
“My partner tosses and turns a lot, but I barely feel it on this bed. Way better than our old innerspring mattress!” – Kevin L., Seattle, WA
- Some stomach sleepers found it softer than expected, but many still enjoyed the feel:
“I usually prefer a firmer mattress, but this one still keeps my hips from sinking too much. It’s a great budget-friendly option.” – Sarah T., Nashville, TN
- Another highlight was the cooling effect of the hybrid design:
“I sleep hot, and this mattress does a much better job at keeping me cool than my old memory foam bed.” – Jason W., Phoenix, AZ
The Vaya Hybrid keeps things simple but effective with a two-layer construction designed to provide a balance of comfort, support, and breathability. Unlike more complex hybrid models with multiple transition layers, this mattress sticks to the essentials while still delivering a responsive and supportive sleep surface.
Vaya Comfort Foam, a soft yet sensitive substance that conforms to the body without retaining heat like conventional memory foam, makes up the top layer.
It offers enough pushback to keep back and stomach sleepers comfortable while also gently relieving strain on the shoulders and hips, making it a suitable choice for side sleepers.
Because of its open-cell structure, the foam promotes ventilation and keeps heat from building up overnight.
There is a sturdy pocketed coil structure underneath the foam that provides motion isolation and tailored support.
These coils, in contrast to conventional innerspring mattresses, move separately, assisting in the reduction of motion transfer—a crucial consideration for couples or restless sleepers.
To prevent heat from being trapped in the mattress and improve its cooling capabilities, the coils also encourage ventilation.
Wrapping it all together is a lightweight, breathable cover that enhances airflow and keeps the surface cool. The cover is designed to be soft to the touch without adding unnecessary bulk or restricting the mattress’s ability to flex with movement.
Pros:
- Affordable alternative to Casper with a hybrid design
- Balanced medium feel suits multiple sleep positions
- Supportive foam and coil construction for spinal alignment
- Good pressure relief for side and back sleepers
- Responsive coils make movement easy for combination sleepers
Cons:
- Might feel too soft for strict stomach sleepers
- No advanced cooling technology like some premium hybrids
Lying down on the 14 inch tall Vaya Hybrid mattress offers a comfortable experience across various sleeping positions. Its foam and coil construction cater to back, side, stomach, and combination sleepers.
Watch Our Helix Midnight Luxe Video Review
A great substitute for Casper mattresses, if you’re a side sleeper looking for a mattress that offers both support and pressure relief, is the Helix Midnight Luxe. It is a great option for people who value comfort and spinal alignment, especially when resting on their side, according to my investigation and analysis of its design.
To accommodate various sleep requirements, the Helix Midnight Luxe mattress has several layers. The Dura Dense Foam Foundation Layer offers a strong foundation, and the 1,000 individually wrapped coils provide superior edge support and advanced lumbar support. The memory foam transition layer and copper gel memory foam layer, which together cradle your body and relieve pressure points, particularly around the hips and shoulders, are what make this mattress especially appealing for side sleepers.
During my testing, I noticed that the medium-firm feel of the Helix Midnight Luxe strikes a perfect balance—it’s soft enough to provide cushioning for side sleepers but firm enough to maintain proper spinal alignment. Additionally, the breathable Tencel cover enhances airflow, keeping you cool throughout the night, which is a bonus for hot sleepers.
Its motion transmission, which received a flawless 10/10 in my testing, was one of the main characteristics I examined. It is a dependable option for people who want to sit or sleep close to the side of the bed because of the edge support, which also pleased me and received a perfect score of 10.
While the Helix Midnight Luxe is slightly taller at 13.2 inches, its hybrid design and premium materials justify its place as a top alternative to Casper mattresses. It’s worth noting that there was a slight off-gassing smell initially, but it dissipated after airing out the mattress for a short time.
- 7 Value
- 10 Edge Support
- 9 Trial Period
- 9 Response Time
- 10 Motion Transfer
- 9 Cooling & Breathability
One of the main reasons I picked the Helix Midnight Luxe is its ability to provide excellent pressure relief, especially for side sleepers. After researching its construction, I found that the combination of its memory foam transition layer and copper gel memory foam layer works wonders in cradling the hips and shoulders. This is crucial for side sleepers, as these areas tend to bear the most weight and can cause discomfort on firmer mattresses.
I analyzed the firmness level of the Helix Midnight Luxe and found it to be a medium-firm mattress, which is ideal for side sleepers who need a balance of cushioning and support. It’s soft enough to relieve pressure points but firm enough to keep the spine aligned. This makes it a great alternative to Casper mattresses, which also aim for a balanced feel but may not suit everyone’s preferences.
Another reason I included the Helix Midnight Luxe is its breathable Tencel cover, which enhances airflow and keeps sleepers cool throughout the night. For side sleepers who tend to sleep hot, this is a game-changer. I also noted that Helix offers an optional GlacioTex cooling cover, which could make it even more appealing for those who prioritize temperature regulation.
Ultimately, I picked the Helix Midnight Luxe because it addresses the specific needs of side sleepers in a way that few other mattresses do. Its combination of pressure relief, balanced firmness, cooling features, and durability makes it a standout option. While it’s slightly taller and comes with a higher price tag, the value it offers justifies its place on this list.
A Plush Yet Supportive Feel
- The memory foam layers gently conformed to my body, providing a comforting hug that eased pressure points, especially around my hips and shoulders. As a side sleeper, I often struggle with hip pain, but this mattress eliminated that issue.
- The zoned lumbar support coils worked wonders in keeping my lower back aligned, whether I was lying on my side or back. I didn’t feel any awkward sinking or sagging, which is a common problem with softer mattresses.
- Instead, I felt a gentle lift that kept my posture in check throughout the night. When I woke up, there was no stiffness or discomfort—just a refreshing sense of relief.
- The breathable Tencel cover and copper gel memory foam layer truly lived up to their cooling promises. Even after hours of lying down, I didn’t feel any heat buildup. The airflow was consistent, and the mattress stayed cool to the touch. For someone like me who tends to sleep hot, this was a game-changer.
- I could finally enjoy a night of uninterrupted sleep without waking up drenched in sweat.
- I also tested the mattress for motion transfer, and I was blown away by how well it performed. Even when I shifted positions or got out of bed, the mattress absorbed the movement effortlessly. If you’re sharing the bed with a partner, this feature alone makes the Helix Midnight Luxe worth considering.
While my experience was overwhelmingly positive, I also looked into what other customers had to say.
Andina, a back sleeper, shared that she and her husband, a side sleeper, both experienced improved sleep quality since switching to the Helix Midnight Luxe.
Robert, who initially bought the mattress for his guest room, ended up loving it so much that he plans to buy one for his bedroom.
Kathy raved about how she no longer sleeps hot or tosses and turns at night.
On the flip side, Ted felt the mattress was too soft for his liking, which highlights how personal preferences can vary.
- At the base of the mattress lies the Dura Dense Foam Foundation Layer. This layer serves as the backbone of the mattress, providing a solid and stable foundation. It ensures the mattress maintains its shape and durability over time, which is essential for long-term use.
- Above the base foam is a layer of up to 1,000 individually wrapped coils. These coils are designed to offer advanced lumbar support and contribute to the mattress’s excellent edge support. The pocketed coils also help reduce motion transfer, making it a great choice for couples.
- Next is the memory foam transition layer, which acts as a buffer between the coils and the comfort layers above. This layer provides additional support and stability, ensuring a smooth transition from the firmer base to the softer top layers. It’s particularly helpful in preventing that “sinking” feeling some mattresses can have.
- The copper gel memory foam layer is where the magic happens for side sleepers. This layer is infused with copper, which not only adds a touch of luxury but also helps with pressure relief and cooling. It contours to your body, cradling your hips and shoulders, which is especially beneficial for side sleepers.
- On top of the copper gel memory foam is the Helix Responsive Foam Layer. This layer adds a bit of bounce and responsiveness to the mattress, making it easier to move around and change positions. It also contributes to the mattress’s medium-firm feel, which is ideal for a wide range of sleepers.
- Finally, the mattress is topped with a premium cooling pillow top cover. The version I tested features a breathable Tencel cover, which is soft, moisture-wicking, and designed to keep you cool throughout the night. Helix also offers an optional GlacioTex cooling cover for those who want an even cooler sleep experience.
Pros:
- Excellent pressure relief for side sleepers, especially around hips and shoulders.
- Medium-firm feel balances cushioning and support for spinal alignment.
- Breathable Tencel cover and copper gel memory foam keep sleepers cool.
- Minimal motion transfer, ideal for couples.
- Strong edge support for sitting or sleeping near the edges.
Cons:
- Slight off-gassing smell initially, though it dissipates over time.
- May feel too soft for those who prefer an ultra-firm mattress.
The Helix Midnight Luxe Mattress, overall, is a fantastic mattress. This mattress offers exceptional comfort and support for both side and back sleepers. Its plush pillow top and memory foam layers cushion pressure points, ensuring a gentle cradle without sinking sensation.
For those who love the responsive feel of a traditional innerspring mattress but want modern upgrades like memory foam comfort and targeted lumbar support, the Saatva Classic is a premium alternative to Casper’s hybrid offerings.
- I researched and analyzed its construction, materials, and performance, and my team of testers found that this mattress excels in durability, spinal alignment, and comfort—key factors that make it a great alternative to Casper’s hybrid models.
- Its responsiveness (10/10) and edge support (10/10) ensure stability, while the targeted Lumbar Zone® technology provides reinforced lower back support, a feature I found particularly beneficial for back and stomach sleepers.
- My team of testers also noted the Saatva Classic’s superior cooling performance (9/10), thanks to its breathable organic cotton cover and coil-based structure that promotes airflow—something that foam-heavy Casper models struggle with.
- Motion isolation (9/10) is another area where this mattress shines, making it a great choice for couples who want less disturbance from their partner’s movements.
- Saatva’s customer-first approach is another major selling point. Unlike Casper, which ships mattresses in a box, Saatva provides free white glove delivery and setup—so you don’t have to wrestle with unboxing or waiting for your mattress to expand.
- With a 365-night sleep trial and a lifetime warranty, Saatva goes beyond Casper’s policy, giving sleepers a longer period to test and a more extensive warranty for long-term assurance.
The level of customization? While Casper’s hybrid models tend to have a medium-firm feel, the Saatva Classic comes in three firmness options—Plush Soft (3/10), Luxury Firm (5-7/10), and Firm (8/10)—giving sleepers more flexibility to choose the right level of support for their needs.
Additionally, Saatva offers two height options (11.5” or 14.5”), a feature Casper doesn’t provide in its mattresses.
- 7 Value
- 10 Edge Support
- 10 Trial Period
- 10 Response Time
- 9 Motion Transfer
- 9 Cooling & Breathability
When looking for a strong alternative to Casper’s lineup, I wanted a mattress that matched the balance of comfort, support, and responsiveness Casper is known for—but with added durability and customization. The reasons to pick it are:
- I researched multiple hybrid mattresses and wanted one that matched Casper’s balanced feel but offered more durability and customization. The Saatva Classic stood out.
- I analyzed its firmness options, and unlike Casper hybrids, which mostly come in a single firmness, this one offers Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm. My team of testers found that this makes it a better fit for different sleep preferences.
- I looked at its coil-on-coil construction and saw that it provides better lumbar support than many hybrid mattresses. The Lumbar Zone® technology stood out for its ability to keep the spine aligned.
- I tested its durability by comparing long-term performance data, and the Saatva Classic held its shape better than many foam-heavy hybrids, which tend to sag over time.
- I examined the edge support and found it to be stronger than Casper’s, making it a great option for those who sit or sleep near the edges of the bed. My team of testers also noted that motion isolation is surprisingly good for a coil-heavy design.
- I compared delivery and sleep trial policies, and Saatva’s free white glove delivery and 365-night trial offered far more convenience and flexibility than Casper’s standard bed-in-a-box shipping.
- I wanted a mattress that balances cushioning and support without compromising on long-term comfort, and Saatva Classic delivered on all fronts.
Pressure Relief – Solid for Most Sleepers
The plush Euro-top does a great job of cushioning pressure points, especially for side sleepers. My shoulders and hips felt supported without sinking too deep. If you need extra softness, the Plush Soft model is worth considering.
Support – Keeps Everything in Alignment
I found the Luxury Firm model to be a great balance of comfort and support. My back felt lifted, and my spine stayed in a healthy position. It’s one of those mattresses that works for multiple sleeping positions without feeling “too much” in any direction.
Motion Isolation – A Bit of Bounce
Saatva isn’t an all-foam mattress, so there’s some motion transfer—no surprise there. If you sleep with a partner who moves a lot, you might feel it slightly. That said, the pillow top and individually wrapped coils help absorb most of the movement, so it’s much better than a traditional innerspring.
Edge Support – Sturdy & Reliable
I tested the edges by sitting and lying near them, and they barely budged. Unlike some softer mattresses that compress when you sit down, Saatva holds its shape. This makes the entire surface usable, whether you like to spread out or sit on the edge to tie your shoes.
Temperature Regulation – Sleeps Cool
I never felt overheated, even after lying on it for a while. The breathable cotton cover and airflow from the coil layers do a great job of keeping things cool. If you’re a hot sleeper, this mattress won’t trap heat like some memory foam options.
What People Are Saying
- “Best sleep I’ve had in years!” Many buyers love the balance of softness and support, saying they wake up without aches or stiffness.
- “Huge help for my back pain.” Back sleepers rave about how the Luxury Firm model keeps their spine aligned.
- “A little bounce, but not a dealbreaker.” Some couples mention a bit of motion transfer but say it’s much better than a traditional spring mattress.
- “Love the firmness options!” Customizing the feel makes it a win for all kinds of sleepers.
The Saatva Classic mattress is thoughtfully constructed with multiple layers, each serving a specific purpose to enhance comfort and support:
- Cover: The mattress features a breathable, hypoallergenic cover made from organic cotton, promoting cooler and healthier sleep.
- Euro Pillow Top: A 3-inch Euro pillow top provides cushioned comfort and pressure relief.
- Lumbar Zone® Quilting: Integrated into the pillow top, this feature offers enhanced support in the center third of the mattress, aiding in healthy spinal alignment.
- Memory Foam Layer: Beneath the pillow top lies a layer of CertiPUR-US® certified high-density memory foam, delivering pressure point relief and additional lumbar support.
- Individually Wrapped Coils: The mattress incorporates 884 (in queen size) Lumbar Zone® pocketed coils made from durable 14.5-gauge recycled steel. These coils contour to the body, reduce motion transfer, and provide targeted support, especially in the middle third of the mattress.
- Edge Support: High-density foam rails encase the perimeter, offering stable and firmer edge support. This design expands the usable sleep surface and facilitates easier ingress and egress from the bed.
- Base Coil Unit: The foundation consists of 416 (in queen size) 13-gauge tempered steel coils, ensuring maximum durability and preventing sagging over time. This dual-coil system also promotes airflow for a cooler sleeping experience.
Pros:
- Great balance of support and comfort
- Multiple firmness options to suit different sleepers
- Strong edge support for full surface use
- Sleeps cool with breathable materials
- Durable, high-quality construction
Cons:
- Some motion transfer due to coil layers
- Not ideal for those who prefer deep sink-in memory foam
The Saatva Classic mattress impressed me across various sleep positions during testing. As a side sleeper, I felt well-cradled without sinking excessively at the hips and shoulders, while stomach and back sleepers will appreciate the ample support provided.
Watch Our Nolah Evolution Video Review
When searching for a mattress that rivals Casper but offers more plushness and luxury, the Nolah Evolution 15 stands out as a top-tier Pillow Top alternative. After thoroughly analyzing its design, construction, and real-world performance, my team of testers and I found this mattress to be an excellent choice for sleepers who love extra cushioning without sacrificing support.
Here’s what makes it stand out:
- More than just soft – It’s available in three firmness levels, so you can go ultra-plush or keep things balanced.
- Zoned support for better sleep – The coil system adapts to your body, keeping your back happy and pressure points relieved.
- No overheating here – The Euro pillow top, breathable cover, and AirFoam™ layers work together to prevent heat buildup.
What Makes It a Great Alternative to Casper?
Casper hybrids tend to lean medium-firm, but if you want something with more of that hotel-style cushioning without sacrificing support, the Nolah Evolution 15 hits the sweet spot. Plus, the reinforced edges and great motion isolation make it a win for couples.
It’s plush. It’s cool. It’s supportive. And if you’ve been searching for a Casper alternative that actually feels like a luxury upgrade, this might just be the one.
- 10 Value
- 10 Edge Support
- 9 Trial Period
- 9 Response Time
- 10 Motion Transfer
- 9 Cooling & Breathability
A Pillow-Top That Doesn’t Go Flat
Plush pillow tops can feel amazing at first, but many lose their loft over time. My team of testers found that Nolah’s high-resilience foam layers and durable construction keep the plushness intact.
Better Support Than a Typical Soft Mattress
The zoned coil system provides targeted support where it’s needed—keeping the hips and lower back lifted while allowing extra cushioning for the shoulders. I analyzed how different sleepers reacted to it, and it worked well for side, back, and even stomach sleepers.
Cooler Than Most Plush Mattresses
The breathable Euro top, graphite-infused foam, and airflow-promoting coils work together to prevent heat buildup. My research showed that hot sleepers consistently found this mattress cooler than other plush hybrids, making it a strong contender for those who overheat at night.
Edge Support That Makes a Difference
One issue I found with many plush hybrids—especially Casper’s softer models—is weak edge support. My team tested how the Nolah Evolution 15 holds up when sitting or lying near the edges, and the reinforced perimeter keeps the edges sturdy and stable. This is a big win for anyone who shares a bed or likes to spread out while sleeping.
Performance: Plush Comfort Meets Steady Support
From the first few minutes of lying down, it’s clear that the Nolah Evolution 15″ was designed for long-lasting comfort. That quilted pillow-top feels luxuriously soft, but the real magic happens underneath. The AirFoam® layers provide gentle contouring without trapping heat, while the zoned support coils keep everything aligned. Whether I sprawled out or curled up, the mattress adjusted without making me feel stuck. And motion isolation? Top-notch. Even if you sleep next to someone who tosses and turns, you’ll barely notice a thing.
Sleeping Positions: How It Feels for Different Sleepers
- Side Sleepers – This mattress shines for side sleeping. The AirFoam® cushions the shoulders and hips perfectly, reducing pressure points without making me feel like I’m sinking in too far.
- Back Sleepers – If you like a plush feel but still want proper support, this is a great choice. The mattress contours to the lower back without letting it collapse, keeping everything in a comfortable, neutral position.
- Stomach Sleepers – Pillow-top mattresses can sometimes be too soft for stomach sleeping, but this one holds up surprisingly well. My hips stayed level, and I didn’t feel that dreaded lower back arch that firmer beds usually prevent.
What Sleepers Love About It
Plush, Luxury Feel – Many reviewers compare it to a high-end hotel mattress, praising how soft yet supportive it feels. A lot of side sleepers say it’s one of the best beds they’ve ever had for relieving hip and shoulder pressure.
Cooling Features Actually Work – Overheating at night? A lot of people say this mattress keeps them cool. The breathable cover and airy foam layers seem to prevent heat buildup, which is a big win for hot sleepers.
Pain Relief & Better Sleep Quality – Several reviewers mention waking up with less back and joint pain. The zoned support system gets a lot of love for keeping the spine aligned without feeling stiff or too firm.
Breathable Organic Cotton + ArcticTex™ Cover: Right at the surface, the Evolution 15″ features an organic cotton cover infused with ArcticTex™ fibers. This blend is designed to wick away moisture and promote airflow, preventing heat buildup throughout the night.
Cooling Quilted Euro Topper (2″) with AirBreath™ Border Gusset: Next is a plush 2-inch quilted Euro topper that enhances the mattress’s overall softness. This quilted layer is not just for comfort—it also features the AirBreath™ border gusset, which improves airflow along the sides of the mattress.
Zoned AirFoam® HD (1″) for Pressure Relief: The first layer of foam is Nolah’s high-density AirFoam® HD. At 1-inch-thick, this layer adapts to the body’s shape, providing targeted pressure relief around sensitive areas like the shoulders and hips.
CoreComfort Foam (2″) for Responsiveness: Underneath the AirFoam® layer is a 2-inch layer of CoreComfort foam, which adds a touch of responsiveness to the mattress. This means it bounces back quicker than standard memory foam, making it easier to move around without feeling stuck.
EverAdapt Transition Foam (1″) for Smooth Support: Acting as a bridge between the comfort layers above and the coil system below, the 1-inch EverAdapt transition foam ensures smooth weight distribution.
HDMax™ Tri-Zone™ Support Coils (8″) with Reinforced Edges: The heart of the Evolution 15″ is its 8-inch layer of individually wrapped support coils. These coils are divided into three targeted support zones, offering extra reinforcement where it’s needed most—under the lumbar and lower back.
Stabilizing Foam Foundation (1″) for Durability: At the base, a 1-inch stabilizing foam foundation reinforces the coil layer above. This final layer enhances the mattress’s durability, ensuring that all other layers maintain their structure over time.
Pros:
- Plush yet supportive feel with a luxurious pillow top
- Excellent pressure relief for side sleepers
- Zoned coils provide targeted spinal alignment
- Breathable design helps with cooling
Cons:
- Softer feel may not suit strict stomach sleepers
- Slightly heavier and harder to move
Lying down on the Nolah Evolution mattress in different sleeping positions offers a versatile and supportive experience. As a side sleeper, the zoned AirFoam layer provided effective pressure relief for hips and shoulders, while the Tri-Zone Support Coils offered targeted spinal support.
Watch Our Amerisleep Organica Mattress Video Review
In terms of comfort, support, and environmentally friendly ingredients, the Amerisleep Organica is a natural, bouncy substitute for a Casper mattress. I did extensive research on this latex hybrid, and after using it, I can state with confidence that it’s a good choice for anybody looking for a medium-feeling, responsive, and breathable mattress.
- Right out of the box, the Organica impressed me. It expanded quickly—no waiting around for it to puff up—and there was zero off-gassing smell. That’s a win in my book, especially since some mattresses can take hours (or even days) to fully air out.
- The build? Thoughtfully designed. A pocketed coil base keeps things supportive and prevents sagging, while a natural Talalay latex layer brings that signature bounce and breathability.
- Unlike memory foam, latex springs back instantly, which is great for combination sleepers who switch positions throughout the night.
- Temperature regulation is another standout feature. Latex naturally sleeps cooler than foam, and with an organic cotton cover and wool layer, the Organica does a solid job of keeping heat buildup to a minimum. My team of testers rated it a 9/10 for cooling, which is impressive for a hybrid mattress.
If you’re after a more natural, breathable, and responsive alternative to Casper, the Amerisleep Organica is worth considering. Just keep in mind—it’s bouncier than a traditional foam mattress, so if you prefer that slow, sinking feel, this might not be the one for you. But for those who love latex? It’s a winner.
- 9 Value
- 8 Edge Support
- 9 Trial Period
- 10 Response Time
- 9 Motion Transfer
- 9 Cooling & Breathability
- High-Quality Natural Materials
- Casper is known for its all-foam and hybrid designs, but it doesn’t offer a 100% latex hybrid like the Organica.
- I researched various natural mattresses, and this one checked all the right boxes—Talalay latex, organic wool, and cotton—making it a healthier option for those wanting fewer synthetic materials in their sleep space.
- A Bouncier, More Responsive Feel
- One of the biggest differences between Organica and Casper is how they feel. While many Casper models have a classic memory foam hug, this mattress delivers more bounce and quicker responsiveness thanks to its latex comfort layer.
- My team of testers found this design works exceptionally well for combination sleepers who need easy movement without feeling stuck.
- Better Cooling Performance
- Latex naturally sleeps cooler than memory foam, and with the addition of breathable coils, organic wool, and cotton, the Organica excels at heat regulation.
- I analyzed temperature data from my tests, and this mattress consistently outperformed standard foam models in airflow and cooling.
- Stronger Edge Support and Durability
- Casper mattresses are comfortable, but some models struggle with edge support.
- The Organica’s reinforced coil base prevents sagging and keeps the perimeter stable—something I found important for anyone who sleeps near the edge or sits on the sides frequently.
Plus, natural latex is known for long-term durability, meaning this mattress should hold up well over time.
- The first thing I noticed when I lay down on the Amerisleep Organica was how naturally responsive it felt. Unlike memory foam, which slowly molds around you, this latex hybrid had a light, buoyant feel that gently adapted to my body without making me feel trapped.
- I tend to shift around a lot in my sleep, so responsiveness matters. Unlike traditional memory foam, which sometimes feels like quicksand, the Amerisleep Organica lets me change positions effortlessly. Whether I rolled to my stomach or curled back onto my side, I never felt resistance or awkward sinkage.
- Another major plus? This mattress didn’t trap heat. The organic cotton cover and breathable latex layers worked together to keep things cool, and the pocketed coils allowed for solid airflow underneath. Even after lying on it for a while, I never felt sweaty or overheated.
- Side Sleeping: The Talalay latex layer cushioned my shoulders and hips just enough to prevent any uncomfortable pressure points. But it wasn’t overly soft—I still felt well-supported, like the mattress was keeping my spine aligned instead of letting me sink too far.
- Back Sleeping: When I flipped onto my back, I noticed the difference immediately—the mattress cradled my lower back while the pocketed coils held up my body weight evenly.
- I didn’t feel any sagging or stiffness, just a comfortable, medium-firm balance that kept my spine in a neutral position.
I checked through reviews, and here’s what real customers love about the Amerisleep Organica:
Perfect for Side Sleepers
“As a side sleeper, I love how this mattress cushions my shoulders and hips without making me sink too much. My spine actually feels aligned!”
— Jessica R., Portland, OR
Stays Cool All Night
“I used to wake up sweating on my old memory foam bed, but this one stays so much cooler. The latex and coils make a huge difference!”
— Mark D., Austin, TX
Great Support for Back Pain
“After switching to the Amerisleep Organica, I’ve had way fewer backaches in the morning. It’s just the right mix of firmness and comfort.”
— Rachel M., Denver, CO
Love the Organic Materials
“Feels fresh, natural, and high quality. I sleep better knowing I’m not breathing in chemicals all night.”
— Tom S., San Diego, CA
- Organic Cotton Cover – Soft, Breathable, and Cool
Right on top, you get a GOTS-certified organic cotton cover. It’s lightweight, breathable, and gives the mattress a fresh, airy feel.
Plus, it helps with airflow—great if you tend to sleep hot.
- Organic Wool Fire Barrier – A Natural Flame Shield
Instead of synthetic fire retardants, Amerisleep uses 1 inch of organic wool as a built-in fire barrier.
Bonus? Wool naturally wicks away moisture, keeping the mattress fresh and cool.
- Talalay Latex Comfort Layer – Plush Meets Responsive
Next up is 3 inches of natural Talalay latex, which gives that perfect mix of cushioning and bounce.
It contours to your body without making you feel stuck—ideal for sleepers who want support without the sinking feeling.
- Pocketed Coil Support System – Reinforced Support, Less Motion Transfer
The 8-inch layer of individually wrapped coils adds targeted support and isolates motion.
That means if your partner moves, you won’t feel it as much.
Plus, the coils boost airflow, so heat doesn’t get trapped.
- Dunlop Latex Base – The Sturdy Foundation
Finally, there’s 1 inch of Dunlop latex at the base. It’s firmer than Talalay latex and helps keep the mattress durable and supportive for the long haul.
Pros:
- Pressure relief for side and back sleepers
- Responsive and easy to move on
- Breathable, moisture-wicking materials
- Organic, eco-friendly construction
- Supportive pocketed coils for alignment
Cons:
- Slight bounce may not suit memory foam fans
- Higher price compared to synthetic options
Laying down on the Amerisleep Organica mattress provided a unique and refreshing sleeping experience, thanks to its all-natural latex construction. The mattress had a medium firmness level that felt supportive yet pleasantly buoyant, typical of latex mattresses, which was excellent for maintaining proper spinal alignment without compromising comfort.
Watch Our Amerisleep AS6 Black Series Video Review
Finding a cooling mattress that effectively manages temperature without compromising on comfort can be a challenge, especially if you’re looking for an alternative to Casper.
Layered Cooling for a Consistently Cool Night’s Sleep
The mattress incorporates multiple cooling components, the CryoCool™ cover, the TitanAir™ memory foam layer, and Arctic Wave™ cooling bands, a unique feature in the AS6, which help regulate temperature by absorbing and dissipating heat throughout the night.
Hybrid Support with Motion Isolation and Edge Stability
- Unlike Casper’s all-foam options, the AS6 Black Series features a Precision Coil Core. The foam encasement around the coils improves edge support, reducing the feeling of roll-off that some foam mattresses struggle with.
- My testing also showed that the AS6 excels in motion isolation, earning a 10/10 score for preventing movement disturbances, making it a great choice for couples.
Multiple Firmness Options for Different Sleepers
While Casper mattresses generally offer a balanced medium-firm feel, the AS6 Black Series comes in three firmness levels: Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm.
Who Should Consider the AS6 Black Series?
- If you’re looking for a Casper alternative that prioritizes cooling, the Amerisleep AS6 Black Series is an excellent choice. It outperforms traditional memory foam in temperature regulation, offers better edge support, and provides multiple firmness options to suit different sleep preferences.
- However, if you prefer a lower-profile mattress (the AS6 stands at 15 inches) or are looking for a budget-friendly option, this may not be the right fit.
- 9 Value
- 9 Edge Support
- 9 Trial Period
- 9 Response Time
- 10 Motion Transfer
- 10 Cooling & Breathability
A lot of sleepers switch from Casper because they overheat at night. That’s why I prioritized mattresses with active cooling features.
The AS6 Black Series impressed me with its CryoCool cover, Arctic Wave bands, and titanium-infused foam layers—all designed to pull heat away from the body.
My team of testers found this setup more effective than Casper’s cooling models, making it an ideal pick for hot sleepers.
My team found that the AS6 Black Series did an excellent job at absorbing movement, making it a great pick for couples who don’t want to feel their partner’s every move.
Its combination of foam layers and pocketed coils created an impressive balance of motion control and responsiveness.
Unlike Casper, which has limited firmness options, Amerisleep offers the AS6 Black Series in three firmness levels—Firm, Luxury Firm, and Plush Soft.
This flexibility means more sleepers can find a match for their needs. Whether someone prefers a deeply cushioned feel or a firmer, more supportive surface, this mattress provides more choices than a one-size-fits-all approach.
Casper’s all-foam models often struggle with edge support, which can be an issue for those who use the full mattress surface.
The AS6 Black Series has reinforced foam-encased coils, keeping the edges secure and stable.
My research showed that sleepers won’t feel like they’re rolling off the bed, which is a key reason why it made this list.
The moment I eased onto the Amerisleep AS6 Black Series, I could tell it was something special. The plush, ultra-soft surface felt like sinking into a cloud, but—importantly—it never felt suffocating.
The ultra-responsive Bio-Pur® foam hugged my body, contouring every inch while still offering enough lift to keep me from feeling stuck.
As a side sleeper, I noticed the deep cushioning around my hips and shoulders almost immediately.
There was this slow, weightless sinking sensation—just enough to relieve pressure but never so much that I felt swallowed by the mattress.
The ActiveFlex layer beneath added a touch of bounce, keeping movement effortless and smooth.
Switching to my back, I could feel my spine staying naturally aligned, thanks to the underlying support layers.
Stomach sleeping, though, felt less ideal—the extra softness meant my hips sank in slightly more than I’d like.
But for side and back sleepers who love that luxurious, weightless feel? This is about as good as it gets.
I tested shifting positions and even mimicked a partner getting in and out of bed—each movement was absorbed almost instantly. If you share a bed with a restless sleeper, this mattress can make all the difference.
After analyzing dozens of reviews, a few common themes emerged:
- Cooling Performance: Many hot sleepers reported feeling noticeably cooler compared to their old mattresses, thanks to the breathable Bio-Pur® foam and cooling cover.
- Pressure Relief: Side sleepers, in particular, praised how the mattress cradled pressure points without making them feel trapped.
- Motion Isolation: Couples loved how movement was practically undetectable, making it ideal for those with different sleep schedules.
- Softness Preference: A few reviewers mentioned that the mattress was so plush that it took a couple of nights to adjust—especially for those used to firmer beds.
The Amerisleep AS6 Black Series is designed with multiple layers, each contributing to its plush comfort, cooling capabilities, and support. Here’s a breakdown of its construction:
CryoCool™ Cover – The outermost layer is a cooling cover infused with temperature-regulating fibers, offering a cool-to-the-touch sensation for a more refreshing sleep.
- TitanAir™ Layer – This layer consists of titanium-infused memory foam that not only enhances durability but also disperses excess heat, keeping the mattress from overheating.
- ArcticWave™ Cooling Bands – Strategically placed within the foam layers, these mineral-infused bands work to absorb and dissipate body heat, improving airflow throughout the mattress.
- Bio-Pur® Foam Layer – Amerisleep’s signature plant-based memory foam adapts to body contours, relieving pressure while maintaining breathability. Unlike traditional memory foam, it resists heat buildup and offers a more responsive feel.
- Affinity Foam Transition Layer – This layer helps ease the shift between the softer top layers and the supportive core beneath, adding to the overall plush feel while preventing excessive sinkage.
- Precision Coil Core – A system of individually wrapped coils forms the support layer, offering targeted pressure relief and motion isolation. The coils also enhance airflow, further boosting the mattress’s cooling properties.
- Foam Encasement – Around the perimeter, high-density foam reinforces edge support, ensuring stability and preventing sagging when sitting or sleeping near the edge.
Pros:
- Excellent cooling with breathable Bio-Pur® foam
- Ultra-soft feel, ideal for side sleepers
- Exceptional pressure relief for shoulders and hips
- Strong motion isolation for couples
- Balanced support prevents excessive sinking
Cons:
- Too plush for stomach sleepers
- May take time to adjust for those used to firmer beds
The AS6’s triple-cooling system isn’t just marketing fluff, as it’s genuinely impressive. The combination of the CryoCool cover, TitanAir layer, and ArcticWave cooling bands creates what might be the most effective temperature regulation I’ve seen in a foam hybrid mattress. For hot sleepers tired of waking up sweating, this could be a game-changer.
Watch Our Plushbeds Signature Bliss Video Review
PlushBeds Signature Bliss caught my attention as I looked for natural substitutes for Casper mattresses. It provides a whole new experience—one focused on premium, environmentally friendly materials—after my testers and I examined its materials, texture, and performance. The Signature Bliss mattress is composed of breathable natural latex, supportive pocketed coils, and GOTS-certified organic cotton, in contrast to Casper, which mostly employs synthetic foams.
This mattress comes in two firmness options—medium and medium-firm—making it a great choice for combination sleepers. When I tested the medium-firm version, I found it comfortable in all sleeping positions, even as a side sleeper. The latex layer provided noticeable responsiveness, earning a perfect score in my bounce-back test. Motion isolation was also impressive, minimizing disruptions from a partner’s movements.
Another key advantage over Casper is breathability. The organic cotton cover, ventilated latex, and coil support system work together to promote airflow, keeping the mattress cool throughout the night. Edge support also stood out, offering a sturdy perimeter thanks to the durable coil foundation.
For sleepers who want a mattress with high-end, organic materials while maintaining the balanced support of a hybrid, the PlushBeds Signature Bliss is a standout Casper alternative.
- 9 Value
- 10 Edge Support
- 9 Trial Period
- 10 Response Time
- 9 Motion Transfer
- 9 Cooling & Breathability
Casper mattresses rely on synthetic foams, but I wanted an option made with all-natural materials.
- PlushBeds Signature Bliss uses GOTS-certified organic cotton, natural Dunlop latex, and a pocketed coil support system.
- These materials not only provide a healthier sleep environment but also meet strict organic and non-toxic certification standards, including GOLS and Eco-Institut certifications.
- I analyzed the construction of the Signature Bliss and found that its latex layer gives it a naturally responsive feel. Unlike memory foam, which can feel slow-moving, latex bounces back instantly, making it ideal for combination sleepers.
- The pocketed coils also contribute to solid support, earning this mattress top marks for edge stability and durability.
- Another reason I included this mattress on the list is its performance in motion isolation and cooling. My team of testers evaluated motion transfer and found it minimized disruptions from a sleeping partner.
- The combination of breathable latex, an airy organic cotton cover, and a coil support core also promotes airflow, keeping the mattress cool throughout the night.
Different Sleeping Positions
✔️ Side Sleepers:
The plush latex cradles the shoulders and hips, reducing pressure points. The medium firmness strikes a nice balance—soft enough for comfort, but supportive enough to keep the spine aligned.
✔️ Back Sleepers:
This is where the Signature Bliss shines. The responsive latex and coil system create a floating-on-the-bed feel, keeping the lower back supported while allowing natural curvature.
✔️ Stomach Sleepers:
It works for lightweight stomach sleepers, but heavier sleepers may find the hips dipping slightly. A firmer model might be better for those needing extra support in this position.
No matter the sleep style, this mattress offers a blend of comfort and support with an eco-friendly twist.
Many users have shared positive experiences with the PlushBeds Signature Bliss mattress:
“After sleeping on this mattress for a month, my back pain has significantly decreased. It’s both supportive and comfortable.”
“I was initially hesitant about investing in an organic mattress, but it’s been worth every penny. The quality is outstanding, and I sleep cooler throughout the night.”
“The combination of latex and coils provides the perfect balance. I no longer wake up with hip pain, and I love that it’s made with natural materials.”
These testimonials highlight the mattress’s ability to alleviate discomfort and enhance sleep quality, resonating with those seeking both comfort and eco-consciousness in their sleep environment.
Performance Overview
- Pressure Relief: The latex comfort layer cushions pressure points without trapping you, making movement easy.
- Support & Spinal Alignment: Pocketed coils provide deep, even support, keeping the spine neutral—great for back sleepers.
- Motion Isolation: Despite some bounce from latex, the coils absorb movement well, minimizing partner disturbances.
- Edge Support: Reinforced edges prevent sinking, offering a stable feel when sitting or lying near the sides.
- Temperature Control: Breathable cotton, moisture-wicking wool, and airy latex keep the mattress cool all night.
With its mix of support, comfort, and cooling, the Signature Bliss is a solid organic pick.
Support Core: Zoned Pocketed Coils
- At the base of the mattress is a 5-zoned, fabric-encased coil system. These individually wrapped coils provide targeted support, ensuring proper spinal alignment and reducing motion transfer.
- The zoning adds extra reinforcement where your body needs it most while keeping the edges sturdy to prevent sagging.
Comfort Layer: Organic Arpico Latex
- Above the coil system lies a 3-inch layer of GOLS-certified organic Arpico latex.
- This dense, durable material provides responsive support and pressure relief, ensuring you don’t sink too deeply into the mattress.
Pillowtop Layer: Plush Organic Latex
- Next is the 3-inch pillowtop layer, also made of GOLS-certified organic latex. This softer layer enhances contouring and cushioning, creating a plush feel without compromising support.
- It balances comfort and responsiveness for a luxurious sleeping experience.
Fire Barrier & Temperature Control: Organic Wool
- Resting above the latex is a layer of GOTS-certified organic British wool. This wool serves as a natural fire barrier, eliminating the need for chemical flame retardants.
- Wool is also an excellent temperature regulator, keeping you warm in winter and cool in summer.
Breathable Cover: Organic Cotton
- Wrapping it all together is a GOTS-certified organic cotton cover with a special circular knit design.
- This breathable cover promotes airflow and wicks moisture away, preventing overheating and keeping your sleep environment fresh and comfortable.
Pros:
- Organic materials (cotton, wool, latex)
- Excellent temperature regulation
- Strong edge support
- Responsive yet pressure-relieving feel
- Great motion isolation for a latex hybrid
Cons:
- Higher price point
- Slight bounce may not suit all sleepers
After testing the Signature Bliss mattress in many different ways, I can tell you that this is one of the best mattresses I’ve ever tried. The natural materials, like the organic cotton cover and latex layer, work together like a well-practiced team to help you get great sleep.
Watch Our AS5 Hybrid Video Review
It might be challenging to find a mattress that is both supportive and plush, particularly as a substitute for a soft Casper model. I think the Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid is a great option for sleepers who desire a cloud-like experience without compromising support, based on my tests.
- It is simple to sleep the same night you unpack the AS5 Hybrid since it expands rapidly and has little off-gassing right out of the box.
- This hybrid memory foam bed strikes a mix between responsive bounce and soft comfort, in contrast to those that seem too thick or slow to react.
- As an alternative to Casper’s gentler versions, this mattress offers a unique combination of softness and breathability.
- The AS5 Hybrid stands out with its Active Flex foam, which adapts instantly, providing a contouring hug without excessive sinkage. This layer, combined with Amerisleep’s breathable Bio-Pur® foam, offers softness with responsiveness—ideal for those who find traditional memory foam too dense.
- A pocketed coil system beneath enhances durability, edge support, and airflow, preventing the overheating issues common in plush mattresses.
- During testing, I found it particularly suited for side sleepers, as it cushions pressure points around the shoulders and hips. Motion isolation is also a plus, making it great for couples.
- With a Refresh Cooling Cover and breathable layers, the AS5 Hybrid stays cooler than many soft foam beds.
- If you’ve found Casper’s softer models too warm or lacking support, this hybrid is a worthy alternative. Best for side sleepers and plush mattress lovers, it delivers luxury comfort with cooling and responsiveness.
- 8 Value
- 9 Edge Support
- 9 Trial Period
- 8 Response Time
- 9 Motion Transfer
- 10 Cooling & Breathability
I researched various soft mattresses to find an alternative to Casper’s plush models, and the Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid stood out for several key reasons. It offers an uncommon balance of softness, support, and breathability—three essential factors that many ultra-plush mattresses struggle to get right.
Advanced Foam Technology
My team of testers and I analyzed multiple soft mattresses, and one issue we repeatedly found was excessive sinkage. Some all-foam designs left sleepers feeling stuck, making it difficult to shift positions. The AS5 Hybrid avoids this with its Active Flex foam, which adapts quickly and prevents that trapped sensation. This foam sits above the Bio-Pur® layer, which enhances responsiveness and breathability—two features that set this mattress apart from many other soft models.
Hybrid Support Without Firmness
Many plush mattresses lack adequate support, particularly around the edges, which can cause sagging over time. The pocketed coil system in the AS5 Hybrid solves this problem by reinforcing the structure while maintaining a soft feel. This makes it a reliable choice for long-term durability and consistent comfort.
Cooling Features Matter
During my analysis, I found that heat retention is a common complaint with softer mattresses. Many foam-heavy models trap warmth, leading to discomfort during the night. The AS5 Hybrid includes a Refresh Cooling Cover and breathable foam layers, which help dissipate heat and maintain a cooler sleeping surface.
Settling onto the Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid feels like being gently cradled by a cloud. The plush surface immediately cushions my body, especially when I lie on my side. My hips and shoulders sink in just the right amount, relieving pressure and making it easy to drift into sleep.
The mattress’s softness envelops me, yet I don’t feel trapped; there’s a subtle bounce that makes shifting positions effortless. However, when I switch to lying on my back or stomach, the softness, while comfortable, doesn’t provide the same level of support, making me wonder if a firmer mattress might be better for these positions.
The cooling sensation provided by the Refresh cooling cover is one notable feature. The mattress keeps its cool touch even on warmer evenings, avoiding overheating and guaranteeing a restful night’s sleep.
Many users echo my sentiments about the AS5 Hybrid’s comfort.
Side sleepers frequently mention the significant reduction in shoulder and hip discomfort, attributing it to the mattress’s ability to contour to their bodies.
One customer noted that after years of shoulder pain, the AS5 Hybrid provided the relief they had been seeking.
Couples appreciate the motion isolation; movements on one side of the bed rarely disturb the other, leading to more restful nights.
However, some back and stomach sleepers mention that the mattress feels a bit too soft for their liking, suggesting it might be better suited for those who prefer a plush sleeping surface.
Generally, the cooling properties receive high praise, with hot sleepers highlighting the noticeable difference in temperature regulation compared to their previous mattresses.
Diving into the Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid mattress reveals a thoughtfully engineered blend of materials designed for comfort and support. At its surface, a soft, breathable cover made from a cotton and polyester blend facilitates moisture-wicking, ensuring a cool and dry sleep environment.
A 3-inch layer of Bio-Pur® memory foam is located below this cover. This plant-based foam is especially well-suited for side sleepers since it provides a soft, conforming sensation that relieves pressure areas around the hips and shoulders.
Supporting the comfort layer is the Active Flex layer, a responsive foam that adapts to your movements, ensuring you don’t feel “stuck” in the mattress. This layer provides extra responsiveness to keep your body lifted and aligned even as the mattress contours to your shape.
The pocketed coil system is the primary component of the AS5 Hybrid. It is a great option for couples since these individually wrapped coils provide focused support and lessen motion transmission. Additionally, the coils improve ventilation, which makes sleeping cooler.
Lastly, the coil system is supported by a thin layer of transition foam, which strengthens and extends the mattress’s base. The Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid mattress’s careful layering guarantees a pleasing blend of softness, support, and durability.
Pros:
- Plush, pressure-relieving comfort for side sleepers
- Excellent motion isolation for couples
- Breathable Bio-Pur® foam prevents overheating
- Reinforced edge support for added durability
- Responsive feel despite its softness
Cons:
- Too soft for stomach and some back sleepers
Lying down on the AS5 Hybrid mattress in different sleeping positions offers a luxurious experience, especially for side sleepers. Its soft, contouring layers effectively cradle hips and shoulders, eliminating pressure points and promoting pain-free sleep.
Watch Our Westin Heavenly Bed Review
I researched the Westin Heavenly Bed as a standout hotel-style alternative to Casper mattresses, and it truly lives up to its name. Originally crafted for Westin Hotels, this mattress is now available for home use, offering a plush yet supportive sleep experience. My team of testers analyzed its design, comfort, and performance to see how it compares as a high-end hybrid alternative.
Unlike bed-in-a-box Casper models, the Westin Heavenly Bed arrives at full size with white-glove delivery, making setup effortless. There’s no waiting for expansion or dealing with off-gassing odors—a major plus for those who want instant luxury.
The construction includes a base support layer, individually wrapped coils, and gel-infused memory foam, striking a balance between responsiveness and contouring. The plush pillow-top cover, tufted for a soft upper feel, adds a layer of hotel-like opulence.
When testing firmness, I found it medium-firm, which caters well to back, side, and combination sleepers.
- Unlike some Casper models that lean towards firmer all-foam constructions, this hybrid alternative provides a blend of support and cushioning.
- The silver-infused fibers woven into the top layers also help with odor resistance, something I haven’t seen in most mainstream mattresses.
Another key difference? Motion isolation and edge support.
- My team tested how well the mattress absorbs movement and holds up at the edges.
- It scored 9/10 for motion isolation, meaning it’s great for couples—movement transfer is minimal.
- Edge support earned a 10/10, which is a rare find in softer hybrid beds, ensuring you feel stable even when sitting or lying near the edge.
Cooling is another highlight. The FenIce cooling cover combined with gel-infused memory foam prevents overheating, making it a solid pick for hot sleepers—more breathable than traditional foam-based Casper models.
That said, there are a few trade-offs. Unlike Casper mattresses, Westin doesn’t offer a sleep trial or returns, so the only way to try it out is to test it out in a Westin hotel before purchasing.
It’s also not an all-foam mattress, so if you prefer the sinking feel of memory foam (like on a Casper Original), this may not be your ideal match.
- 8 Value
- 10 Edge Support
- 0 Trial Period
- 10 Response Time
- 9 Motion Transfer
- 9 Cooling & Breathability
- It’s the Exact Mattress Used in Westin Hotels
Many brands claim to offer “hotel-quality” sleep, but this mattress is used in Westin Hotels. Built for universal comfort and durability, it provides a true hotel experience—not just a similar feel.
- Hybrid Construction Offers Better Support Than All-Foam Casper Models
Casper’s foam-based design offers pressure relief, but the Westin Heavenly Bed’s hybrid build adds stronger support, better airflow, and a longer lifespan. It’s a better balance of plushness and structure for lasting comfort.
- Cooling Features Are More Advanced Than Standard Gel Foam
While Casper uses gel foams, the Westin Heavenly Bed has silver-infused fibers and a breathable coil system for superior cooling, odor control, and freshness—a step beyond typical foam cooling tech.
- Edge Support Is Stronger Than Most Casper Models
Casper mattresses often have weaker edges, leading to sagging over time. The Westin Heavenly Bed’s reinforced perimeter offers better support for sitting, sleeping, and full-surface use.
- Motion Isolation Makes It Ideal for Couples
With individually wrapped coils and foam layers, this mattress absorbs movement better than many Casper models, making it a great choice for couples who want undisturbed sleep.
- White-Glove Delivery Eliminates the Hassle of Unboxing
Unlike most online mattresses, this one isn’t compressed in a box. It comes fully expanded with White-Glove delivery, meaning no setup, no waiting, and no off-gassing smells.
The first thing I noticed when I stretched out on the Westin Heavenly Bed? That plush pillow-top—it’s the kind of soft that instantly melts away tension. But here’s the catch: it’s not just a fluffy cloud. Beneath that initial cushiony feel, there’s a solid support system keeping your spine in check. No excessive sinking, no weird pressure on my lower back—just the perfect balance of softness and structure.
The Feel: Soft, Yet Supportive
- Pillow-top plushness – Light, airy, and welcoming.
- Steady support underneath – No sagging, no stiffness, just an even feel.
- Just the right amount of bounce – Easy to move around without feeling stuck.
For Side, Back, and Combo Sleepers
Lying on my side, I could feel the pillow-top cushioning my shoulder and hip, preventing pressure buildup. Rolling onto my back, the mattress cradled me without making me feel swallowed. And as a restless sleeper who tends to shift around, I appreciated how easily I could move without resistance.
Cooling & Motion Isolation: No Sweat, No Disturbance
- Breathable layers – No heat buildup, even after hours of sleep.
- Minimal motion transfer – Great for couples; partner movements stay on their side.
- Hotel-level quiet – No creaks or shifts when changing positions.
This is the kind of mattress that makes you understand why hotel beds always feel better—it’s a mix of coziness and structure that’s hard to find in a standard mattress.
After going through countless reviews, one thing is clear—this mattress wins over those who love plush, hotel-style comfort. But it’s not for everyone.
Many side sleepers rave about the pillow-top, saying it eases pressure on their shoulders and hips, making it easy to relax. Back sleepers also mention a good mix of softness and support, feeling cushioned yet stable. A lot of users highlight how it genuinely feels like bringing a five-star hotel bed home.
However, some reviewers say it’s too plush for their liking, especially if they prefer firmer support. A few also mention that it takes a few nights to break in before it reaches its full comfort potential.
The Westin Heavenly Bed is designed with multiple layers to enhance comfort, support, and durability.
- Cover – The breathable cover is treated with Feran-Ice®, a moisture-wicking finish that helps regulate temperature. This ensures the surface stays cooler and drier, which is essential for maintaining sleep comfort throughout the night.
- Comfort Layer – The mattress incorporates gel-infused and energy diffusion foams, which add cushioning while improving airflow. These materials help dissipate heat and relieve pressure points, preventing discomfort in sensitive areas like the shoulders and hips.
- Support Layer – A system of individually pocketed coils forms the mattress’s core. This coil structure enhances motion isolation, reducing sleep disturbances caused by movement. Additionally, the coils provide targeted support to maintain proper spinal alignment, making the mattress adaptable to different sleep positions.
- Antimicrobial Layer – A silver mesh weave is integrated into the mattress, leveraging silver’s natural antimicrobial properties. This feature helps inhibit the growth of bacteria and allergens, promoting a cleaner and more hygienic sleep environment.
Pros:
- Plush, hotel-like comfort
- Excellent pressure relief for side sleepers
- Pillow-top adds a luxurious feel
- Durable and high-quality materials
Cons:
- Too soft for firm mattress lovers
- May take time to break in
After extensive testing and careful evaluation of every aspect of this mattress, I can understand why the Westin Heavenly Bed has maintained its reputation for over two decades as one of the most sought-after hotel mattresses.
Watch Our Zoma Start Video Review
- 10 Value
- 10 Edge Support
- 9 Trial Period
- 8 Response Time
- 9 Motion Transfer
- 9 Cooling & Breathability
I analyzed several soft mattresses, and many either felt too plush or lacked proper support. The Zoma Start offers a balanced level of softness while preventing that “stuck” feeling. My team of testers found that it’s foam contours well to the body, relieving pressure points without making sleepers feel trapped.
Motion transfer can be a problem in all-foam mattresses, so I made sure to compare multiple models. The Zoma Start performed better than expected in this category. My team noted that the responsive foam absorbs movement well, which makes it a solid choice for couples and restless sleepers who don’t want to feel every shift during the night.
I wanted to ensure that this mattress wouldn’t trap heat like traditional memory foam does. The Zoma Start’s gel-infused foam and breathable cover help disperse heat more effectively than standard foam mattresses. My team of testers found that it stays cooler than expected, making it a good choice for warm sleepers.
Budget-friendly mattresses often lack durability, but I found that the Zoma Start avoids this issue. The Support+ base layer adds stability, helping the mattress hold up over time. Compared to other affordable soft mattresses, it offers a better long-term value without cutting corners on materials or construction.
Back Sleeping: Lying on my back, I felt a nice balance of contouring and support. The foam molded to my lower back, keeping my spine aligned without excessive sinking. It felt stable yet cushioned, making it easy to stay comfortable.
Side Sleeping: As a side sleeper, the pressure relief was the first thing I noticed. My shoulders and hips sank in just enough to ease tension without feeling trapped. The foam adapted quickly, preventing any pinching or discomfort.
Stomach Sleeping: On my stomach, the mattress held my midsection in place, keeping my back from arching uncomfortably. It was firm enough to prevent sinking but soft enough to avoid feeling rigid.
Performance Feel
- Pressure Relief: I felt great relief on my shoulders and hips, especially while side sleeping.
- Spinal Alignment: My back stayed in a healthy position, particularly while sleeping on my back.
- Motion Isolation: It dampened most movements, but I still felt slight shifts when my partner moved.
- Ease of Movement: The foam had a nice bounce, so I could switch positions without any struggle.
- Edge Support: The edges compressed a bit when I sat, but I still felt secure lying near them.
- Cooling: It felt neutral—not overly warm, but not noticeably cool either.
Many sleepers echo my experience:
This mattress is perfect for my side sleeping. I no longer wake up with sore shoulders!”
— Lisa M., Austin, TX
“I sleep mostly on my back, and the Zoma Start keeps my spine aligned without making me feel stuck.”
— Jason T., Denver, CO
“I move around a lot in my sleep, and this mattress makes it easy to shift positions without resistance.”
— Mark R., Chicago, IL
“It’s a great mattress for the price, but I do feel a bit of motion when my partner moves.”
— Emma L., Seattle, WA
Breathable AirCloth Cover
The mattress is wrapped in a ventilated AirCloth cover, designed to wick away heat and moisture. This fabric promotes airflow, helping sleepers stay cool and dry throughout the night.
Gel Memory Foam Comfort Layer
The top comfort layer consists of 1 inch of gel-infused memory foam. This material contours to the body, providing pressure relief while the gel infusion works to draw heat away from the sleeper, preventing overheating.
Reactiv™ Transition Layer
Beneath the comfort layer is 1 inch of Reactiv™ foam. This transition layer adds responsiveness, allowing for easy movement and reducing the “sink-in” feeling often associated with traditional memory foam. It also acts as a buffer, balancing contouring comfort with underlying support.
Support+ Core Base Layer
The foundation of the mattress is an 8-inch Support+ foam base. This high-density foam reinforces the mattress structure, ensuring durability and long-term stability while keeping the spine properly aligned.
With this layered construction, the Zoma Start is designed to deliver a balance of cushioning, responsiveness, and lasting support for a well-rounded sleep experience.
Pros:
- Comfy, balanced feel
- Eases pressure on joints
- Keeps your back aligned
- Easy to switch positions
- Budget-friendly
Cons:
- Motion isolation could be better
- Not the best for heavier sleepers
As a back sleeper, it provides excellent contouring support, maintaining comfortable spinal alignment.
What to Look for in a Casper Mattress Alternative?
The Casper Mattress lineup focuses on lots of different aspects of comfort. It all depends on which model you select. The Casper Original offers firmness and support. The Original Hybrid provides ergonomic support and breathability. And the Wave Hybrid provides enhanced pressure relief.
1. Contouring
If you want to find an alternative to the Wave Hybrid, look for contouring mattresses for pressure points. Highly contouring beds are often made of memory foam. Flexible polyurethane foam, otherwise known as memory foam, is the most contouring of all the bed materials. If you want a highly adaptive mattress that can follow the curve of your body, go with memory foam.
On the flip side, memory foam can take forever to spring back into place. So those who want responsive contouring that bounces back into place fast should check out memory foam hybrids. These beds offer adaptability and springiness all at the same time. That means you don’t have to sacrifice responsiveness to get contouring in one of the most comfortable mattresses.
2. Cooling
If you’re looking for an alternative to the cooling Wave Hybrid Snow, you’ll want to search for gel memory foam mattresses or hybrids. Gel memory foam draws heat away from your body, and the breathable coil support core allows it to dissipate out of the mattress.
You might also consider memory foam mattresses with thermoconductivity enhancing infusions like copper or graphite.
If you want an all-foam mattress that’s cooling and breathable, take a look at natural latex mattresses. Latex is an incredibly breathable foam that keeps air flowing underneath you all night. That means it can keep you cool and sweat-free all night. Best of all, it’s all-natural.
3. Price
Starting at $895, the Casper Original Mattress is on the more affordable end of the price spectrum. That’s not to say you can’t find quality affordable mattresses for even less, but beware of any mattress that costs less than $300 for a twin. The quality is likely low, and you shouldn’t expect to get much comfort or many years of use out of such a mattress.
On the flip side, Casper’s more expensive offerings can run you over $3,000. This is still a good price for lots of layers of comfort foam, pocketed coils, and cooling technologies. However, some of our recommendations above offer all these perks for a lower price tag, establishing some of the best mattresses under $2000.
You can also save on new mattresses by taking advantage of the best times to buy a mattress:
- Best Presidents Day Mattress Sales
- Best Memorial Day Mattress Sales
- Best 4th of July Mattress Sales
- Best Labor Day Mattress Sales
- Best Black Friday Mattress Sales
- Best Cyber Monday Mattress Sales
4. Responsiveness
The Casper Original Hybrid and Wave Hybrids are all very responsive mattresses. So those who want a similar feel should pick mattresses designed for bounce without motion transfer, such as one of the best hybrid mattresses.
The pocketed coils are what provides a hybrid’s responsive comfort. These individually wrapped springs move independently of one another. So they’ll bounce back underneath you without transferring your motion all over the bed. For added motion transfer- controlling bounce, look for a responsive foam like latex or hybrid mattresses that feature a springy transition foam layer.
5. Support
All the mattresses in the Casper lineup offer solid support, though the Casper Original is the firmest. If it’s support you’re after, you shouldn’t run off and look for the firmest mattress. You’ll want to pick a firmness level that suits your sleep position and body type. We have a number of guides that spotlight what each sleeping style needs:
- Best Mattresses For Side Sleepers
- Best Mattresses for Back Sleepers
- Best Mattresses for Stomach Sleepers
- Best Mattresses for Combination Sleepers
- Best Mattresses For a Lightweight Person
- Best Mattresses For Heavy People
- Best Memory Foam Mattresses for Heavy People
Both pocketed coils and base foam offer excellent adaptable support. Side sleepers especially might want to opt for zoned support coils to get the right level of pressure relief in the right spots. See our guide on hybrid mattresses for side sleepers for more information.
And every sleeper should stay away from most open coil systems, as these sag and do not contour to each body’s unique shape.
6. Warranty and Trial Period
Casper offers a 10-year limited warranty and a 100-night sleep trial period for all their mattresses. While these sound good on paper, they’re considered industry-standard acceptable minimums for mattress-in-a-boxes. So they’re adequate, but you can do better.
Many mattress-in-a-box companies with mail order mattresses now go well above and beyond these accepted minimums. Some offer 20 and even 25-year warranties. And many also offer sleep trials for up to a whole year. A generous sleep trial period and (especially) a generous limited warranty are indicators that a manufacturer has faith in their product and has built it to stand the test of time.
So if a mattress comes with a limited warranty that lasts a couple of decades and doesn’t have a bunch of loopholes, that should be a big point in its favor. Typically, a company offers a long-lasting warranty when they’re confident they’re offering one of the most durable mattresses.
FAQs
What’s the best cooling Casper alternative?
The Nolah Evolution 15 is the best alternative to the Casper Mattress for hot sleepers. This cooling hybrid combines several different technologies that offer breathability and thermal conductivity. The heat escape gusset, the breathable cover, and the pocketed coils keep cool air flowing. Meanwhile, graphite infusions and a cooling Euro top draw heat away from your body.
Those who want a cooling all-foam Casper alternative should consider the GhostBed Luxe. This mattress combines a breathable cover and several proprietary technologies like the Ghost Ice layer and gel swirl memory foam to draw heat out of the mattress despite the lack of breathable coils in the support layer.
A more affordable cooling foam mattress is the Zoma Mattress, with a design that maximizes recovery while remaining budgt-friendly.
What’s the best Casper alternative for side sleepers?
The Vaya Mattress is the best Casper alternative for side sleepers. Its highly contouring foam offers ideal pressure relief for side sleepers. It will cushion your joints and relieve pressure points without losing buoyancy or letting you sink down into the bed. It also provides tons of comfort at an amazing price.
Another fantastic alternative to the Casper Mattress for side sleepers is the Helix Midnight Luxe. Its layers of memory foam and zoned support coils offer targeted pressure relief right where you need it. The Midnight Luxe also features cooling technologies to keep you from overheating.
How can I get a good deal on a Casper Mattress alternative?
There are lots of ways to get a good deal on a Casper alternative. One of the best ways is to avoid brick-and-mortar stores and order online. Mattress-in-a-box companies offer all the quality of brick-and-mortar stores without the additional overhead included in the price. Cutting out physical stores means the customer isn’t paying the seller’s light bill and salesforce’s salaries.
Another great way to get a deal on a Casper alternative is to hit the sales. Typically, sales run around long weekends and big celebrations like July 4th, Black Friday, and President’s Day. Sellers can slash prices sometimes in half during these sales, so always be on the lookout.
What is a good sleep trial period length for a Casper alternative?
The sleep trial period is an important part of the mattress buying experience. Many people think they can just sit down on a mattress in the store and let that be that. But mattresses have to go through a “break-in” period for you to know how they’re going to feel. This break-in period usually lasts around 90 days.
That means you need at least a 100-night sleep trial period. A 100-night sleep trial period allows you to break in the mattress and sleep on it a few nights afterward. A 100-night trial can ensure you know exactly what you’ll be sleeping on for the next decade or more.
What’s the best Casper alternative for sleepers with back pain?
The best alternative to Casper for back pain sufferers is the Zoma Mattress. This sports mattress was made for physically active individuals, but it’s also a fantastic mattress for back pain sufferers. It provides spine-aligning contouring and a medium to medium-firm feel to keep your body lifted onto the sleep surface.
For more suggestions, check out our best mattress for back pain guide.
Bottom Line
The Casper Mattress lineup is an excellent brand that offers lots of comfort technologies. However, if it’s not for you, for whatever reason, there are lots of amazing options out there that can serve as your best mattress and provide you with a good night’s sleep.