Best Casper Mattress Alternatives

Those who want a more natural alternative to the Casper Mattress lineup should check out the plant-based AS3 by Amerisleep. This plant-based memory foam mattress offers natural comfort in place of pure polyurethane foam. So it’s one of the best mattresses for those who want natural ingredients but cannot have latex.

How the Mattress Feels

The AS3 features Amerisleep’s plant-based Bio-PurⓇ foam. This foam features plant oils instead of some of the petroleum products used to make traditional memory foam. The substitution of plant oils fixes a lot of the issues inherent to traditional memory foam.

For example, the plant-based foam is even more contouring than regular memory foam. At the same time, it’s also more responsive and breathable. That means it can bounce back when you move and keep you cool better than traditional memory foam.

What It’s Made Of

The first layer of the AS3 is the Refresh Cover. This breathable cover keeps cool air flowing and converts your body heat into far infrared energy to ensure you never overheat.

The breathable and cool Bio-PurⓇ foam comfort layer comes next. This layer contours to your shape to relieve pressure points and pain. It also wicks away heat and sweat to keep you cool all night.

Next, the HIVEⓇ transition layer offers five zones of pressure relief to offer each of your body’s areas the exact balance of support and cradling it needs.

Finally, the Bio-CoreⓇ base foam supports your body to keep you on top of the bed rather than allowing you to sink into it. This durable foam also helps ensure your mattress will last its entire 20-year limited warranty and satisfy you throughout its 100-night sleep trial period.

SEE ALSO: Amerisleep vs Casper vs Purple

If you’re an athlete or even just have an active lifestyle, the Zoma Sports Mattress could be for you. This durable medium offering is designed to cradle tired joints and support the body for maximum overnight recovery. It’s also among the best mattresses for back pain sufferers, especially if said back pain is due to long days of physical work.

How the Mattress Feels

The Zoma is a medium to medium-firm mattress, so the first thing you’ll notice lying down on it is its amazing support. You’ll never have to worry about sinking or sagging with this medium-firm mattress. It will keep you lifted on top of the bed and your spine aligned.

The Zoma is also extremely responsive for a memory foam mattress. This is all thanks to its Reactiv™ memory foam layer that springs back into place as soon as you move. So active sleepers can still get a great night’s sleep on this memory foam mattress.

What It’s Made Of

The Zoma starts off with its ventilated AirCloth cover. This cover helps keep cool air moving through the foam layers below to ensure proper temperature regulation.

Underneath the cover, you’ll find a top layer of gel memory foam that pulls your body heat away from you and pushes it deeper into the mattress to maintain a cool sleep surface. This layer features additional contouring in the head and foot of the bed through Triangulex™ technology.

Next up, the Reactiv™ transition foam layer ensures the cooling gel foam comfort layer above springs back into shape as soon as you move. That way, you won’t have to worry about body impressions or slow response time when you change sleep positions.

Finally, a layer of Support+ foam brings up the base of the Zoma. This ultra-durable foam helps give the Zoma its medium feel that fights sinkage and sagging. It also ensures the Zoma will last a full decade, which is why this mattress comes with a 10-year limited warranty and a 100-night sleep trial period.

If you’re shopping for a new mattress on a tight budget, check out the Vaya Mattress. This simple, two-layered mattress cuts down on design complexity to offer high quality at an affordable price. So even those looking at the lower end of the price spectrum can still get a good night’s sleep.

How the Mattress Feels

The Vaya Mattress is technically a medium-feel mattress. This makes it highly versatile for combination sleepers who like to change things up while they sleep or couples who need to compromise on firmness. The Vaya is also the perfect guest room mattress because it’s versatile and affordable.

Don’t let the medium feel fool you, though. The Vaya’s ultra-contouring foam means it’s still perfect for side sleepers because it can cradle sensitive pressure points to prevent pain while fighting sinkage at the same time.

What It’s Made Of

The Vaya’s comfort layer is made of Vaya’s ultra-contouring Comfort Foam. This open-cell foam is designed for maximum contouring as well as maximum breathability. So you won’t have to worry about the sleep surface overheating even as the plush memory foam hugs your body.

The support layer of the Vaya is high-density polyfoam. This ultra-durable Vaya Base Foam offers the right balance of support to counter sinkage in the soft top layer. It also ensures the Vaya Mattress will live up to its 10-year limited warranty and 100-night sleep trial period.

Both these comforting layers are wrapped in a plush and breathable cover to ensure you get maximum softness and coolness all night long.

Those interested in an alternative to the Casper Wave Hybrid Snow should check out another amazing cooling mattress designed for keeping hot sleepers pleasantly chilled all night. The Nolah Evolution 15 features multiple technologies for enhancing breathability and increasing thermal conductivity to keep your skin at the ideal sleep temperature.

How the Mattress Feels

The Evolution comes with three firmness levels. So it can be as plush or as firm as you need it. Choose the plush mattress if you sleep on your side and the firm mattress if you sleep on your stomach. Combo and back sleepers can go for the luxury firm option for a balance of support and pressure relief.

Of course, the Evolution is a cooling mattress, so the first thing you’ll notice when you lie down is its cool-touch feel. And don’t think this feel will dissipate as the night wears on. The Evolution is designed to maintain its cool temperature throughout the night.

What It’s Made Of

The first layer of the Evolution is the ArcticTexTM cover and the cooling, quilted Euro top. These two layers are breathable enough on their own, but they sit atop the AirBreathTM heat escape gusset. This gusset runs the entire perimeter of the mattress and works all night to push hot air out and let cool air in.

Underneath the gusset, the graphite-infused memory foam comfort layer draws body heat even further away from you. And two transition layers of high-resilience and high-density foam increase the buoyancy of the plush layers above.

Finally, the HDMaxTM coils offer 25 percent more support than standard coil systems. They also provide three separate zones of support to ensure each of your body’s areas gets the exact balance of lift and cushioning you need.

If you don’t want to give up the feel of an innerspring mattress but do want to up your mattress’s contouring and pressure relief to get closer to what a Casper Mattress would offer, consider the Saatva Classic.

This adaptable innerspring hybrid mattress fixes a lot of the regular innerspring mattress’s issues without losing the innerspring feel. That means it might just be the best mattress for innerspring lovers on the market.

How the Mattress Feels

Of course, innerspring mattresses are bouncy. And the Classic doesn’t lose that bounce for contouring power and motion isolation like many hybrids do. So if you enjoy a bed that has a little spring in its step, you’ll probably like the feel of the Classic.

However, unlike a regular innerspring mattress that has no motion transfer control and no adaptability, the Classic has these things in spades. That means you can enjoy all the bounce you want without it transferring all over the bed. You can also enjoy the coolness of open coils without sacrificing the adaptability of pocketed ones.

What It’s Made Of

The Classic pulls off its unique feel through a combination of dual coil cores and soft foams and fibers. It starts with the plush cotton cover. This cover is treated with a botanical antimicrobial solution to keep your bed free of allergens.

Below the hypoallergenic cover is a three-inch plush Euro top that helps relieve pressure and increase contouring. This soft topper is made more supportive and buoyant by a layer of high-density memory foam just below it.

Under this support-enhancing memory foam, you’ll find the first layer of support coils. These pocketed coils all move independently of one another to ensure you get maximum adaptability out of this innerspring mattress.

Below the pocketed coils, a layer of open coils makes the Classic an innerspring with all the bounce and airflow you’d expect. This open coil support system is surrounded on all sides by high-density foam rails that help add stability and edge support. That’s why the Classic will last up to 15 years – well beyond the average innerspring life expectancy.

Those who need a memory foam mattress but don’t want to spend the night sweating it out should consider the GhostBed Luxe. This cooling memory foam mattress is so pleasantly chilly you’ll forget it’s all-foam. That means it’s likely the best mattress for hot sleepers who don’t want a hybrid.

How the Mattress Feels

The Luxe features multiple cooling technologies that enhance thermal conductivity and breathability. So the first thing you’ll notice about it is its cool-touch feel that starts off strong and lasts all night long.

Another thing you’ll note about the Luxe is its fantastic contouring ability. This is a medium-soft memory foam mattress, so it can contour and cradle like just about no other. That makes it perfect for side sleepers and others who need extra cushioning.

What It’s Made Of

The Luxe starts off with GhostBed’s cooling three-layer cover. The first layer of the cover is the cooling and plush Ghost Ice fabric. Underneath the breathable fabric is a thin layer of gel memory foam and another layer of cool burst fibers to bring up the bottom.

Underneath the cover, the Ghost Ice layer and a comfort layer of cooling gel memory foam help to transfer heat away from your body and deeper into the mattress.

Next up, the Ghost Bounce layer ensures all that gel memory foam doesn’t experience issues like body impressions or slow response time. It’s springy like latex but without all that pesky potential to trigger allergies.

Finally, the ultra-dense foam support core counters sinkage in the soft layers above to ensure you’re sleeping on top of your mattress and not folded into it. This layer also ensures the Luxe will fight sagging and aging for a full 25 years, which is why it comes with a 25-year limited warranty and a 101-night sleep trial period.

Many all-foam mattresses feature gel memory foam nowadays. But the Purple Plus has a lot more than that. It boasts Purple’s proprietary Purple Grid. This hyperelastic gel polymer offers even more cooling and contouring than a gel foam mattress alone.

How the Mattress Feels

The Purple Grid is the star of the show in this mattress. The Plus features a two-inch-thick GelFlex Grid that responds to your movements and flexes around your pressure points to offer cradling that springs back into shape in an instant.

The Grid is also about 80 percent air. That means it can wick away sweat and heat to keep you cool all night. And its gel material is thermoconductive, so it draws heat away at the same time.

Mattress Construction

The Purple Plus Mattress starts off with the SoftFlex knit cover designed to let you feel all the benefits of the Purple Grid. Directly underneath this cover sits the Grid itself. That means you’ll get the full impact of all that airflow and responsiveness.

Supporting the Grid are three layers of foam. A layer of premium comfort foam increases pressure relief and softness over what the Purple Original Mattress has to offer. And two layers of original comfort foam provide support and buoyancy to keep you on top of the Purple Grid.

See also our guide to popular Purple mattress alternatives.

One of the best Casper Mattress alternatives for those who want a top-notch hybrid mattress is the Tuft & Needle Hybrid. This hybrid mattress doesn’t just feature the standard combination of memory foam and coils. It also has a layer of nano coils and a Mint layer for even more cooling and breathability.

How the Mattress Feels

The Tuft & Needle Hybrid mattress features two layers of coils and two layers of foam arranged in alternating order. That gives it an even more contouring and adaptive feel than your average hybrid mattress.

With its Mint layer, nano coils, and graphite infusions, the Tuft & Needle Hybrid is also extremely cooling. This hybrid mattress can trap heat to pull it away from your body in a way that not many other mattresses can. That makes it among the best Casper Mattress alternatives for hot sleepers.

What It’s Made Of

The Tuft & Needle Hybrid starts off with a quilted pillow top that cradles without sinking. This pillow top leads directly to the first of two foam layers. This layer of open-cell, graphite-infused memory foam helps draw heat away and keep cool air flowing all at once.

The next layer is the first coil layer. These nano coils increased adaptability, bounce, and breathability all at once. The Mind layer is the second of the two foam layers. This foam helps increase breathability and adaptability even further.

Under the nano coils and the two layers of foam sits the pocketed coil support layer. This layer offers full-size coils that adapt to your shape. They also feature a reinforced perimeter to offer edge support without impeding airflow throughout the Tuft & Needle Hybrid.

Those looking for luxury Casper Mattress alternatives should consider the Helix Midnight Luxe. This hybrid mattress pulls out all the stops to offer the feeling of luxury without the multi-thousand dollar luxury price tag.

How the Mattress Feels

The Midnight Luxe is a true hybrid mattress, so it offers a combination of breathability, adaptability, and responsiveness. And just like a hybrid should, it offers all these features with an incredible level of motion isolation.

Back sleepers will also appreciate the zoned coils in this mattress. It’s a little softer than the mattresses normally recommended for back sleepers. But the Midnight Luxe hybrid features enhanced lumbar support in the middle. This can keep both back sleepers and side sleepers aligned and happy, especially those who prefer a softer mattress.

What It’s Made Of

The Midnight Luxe offers a choice between two cooling covers. You can pick breathable TENCELTM or thermoconductive GlacioTex. Either way, the cover sits directly on top of a cooling premium pillow top and a layer of gel memory foam to draw heat away.

Below, a layer of gel visco offers even more cooling as well as extra bounce to keep active sleepers happy as they toss and turn. And a lower layer of high-grade polyfoam provides ergonomic support and buoyancy.

Finally, a layer forof up to more than 1,000 pocketed coils offers a softer feel under the hips and shoulders and a firmer feel under the back. That’s what makes this mattress a solid choice for both side sleepers and back sleepers alike. Some lighter-weight stomach sleepers might even find the zoned coils have enough lift to keep them aligned.

What to Look for in a Casper Mattress Alternative

The Casper Mattress lineup focuses on lots of different aspects of comfort. It all depends on which model you select. The Casper Original offers firmness and support. The Original Hybrid provides ergonomic support and breathability. And the Wave Hybrid provides enhanced pressure relief.

Contouring

If you want to find an alternative to the Wave Hybrid, look for contouring mattresses for pressure points. Highly contouring beds are often made of memory foam. Flexible polyurethane foam, otherwise known as memory foam, is the most contouring of all the bed materials. If you want a highly adaptive mattress that can follow the curve of your body, go with memory foam.

On the flip side, memory foam can take forever to spring back into place. So those who want responsive contouring that bounces back into place fast should check out memory foam hybrids. These beds offer adaptability and springiness all at the same time. That means you don’t have to sacrifice responsiveness to get contouring in one of the most comfortable mattresses.

Cooling

If you’re looking for an alternative to the cooling Wave Hybrid Snow, you’ll want to search for gel memory foam mattresses or hybrids. Gel memory foam draws heat away from your body, and the breathable coil support core allows it to dissipate out of the mattress.

You might also consider memory foam mattresses with thermoconductivity enhancing infusions like copper or graphite.

If you want an all-foam mattress that’s cooling and breathable, take a look at natural latex mattresses. Latex is an incredibly breathable foam that keeps air flowing underneath you all night. That means it can keep you cool and sweat-free all night. Best of all, it’s all-natural.

Price

Starting at $895, the Casper Original Mattress is on the more affordable end of the price spectrum. That’s not to say you can’t find quality affordable mattresses for even less, but beware of any mattress that costs less than $300 for a twin. The quality is likely low, and you shouldn’t expect to get much comfort or many years of use out of such a mattress.

On the flip side, Casper’s more expensive offerings can run you over $3,000. This is still a good price for lots of layers of comfort foam, pocketed coils, and cooling technologies. However, some of our recommendations above offer all these perks for a lower price tag, establishing some of the best mattresses under $2000.

You can also save on new mattresses by taking advantage of the best times to buy a mattress:

• Best Presidents Day Mattress Sales
• Best Memorial Day Mattress Sales
• Best 4th of July Mattress Sales
• Best Labor Day Mattress Sales
• Best Black Friday Mattress Sales
• Best Cyber Monday Mattress Sales

Responsiveness

The Casper Original Hybrid and Wave Hybrids are all very responsive mattresses. So those who want a similar feel should pick mattresses designed for bounce without motion transfer, such as one of the best hybrid mattresses.

The pocketed coils are what provides a hybrid’s responsive comfort. These individually wrapped springs move independently of one another. So they’ll bounce back underneath you without transferring your motion all over the bed. For added motion transfer- controlling bounce, look for a responsive foam like latex or hybrid mattresses that feature a springy transition foam layer.

Support

All the mattresses in the Casper lineup offer solid support, though the Casper Original is the firmest. If it’s support you’re after, you shouldn’t run off and look for the firmest mattress. You’ll want to pick a firmness level that suits your sleep position and body type. We have a number of guides that spotlight what each sleeping style needs:

• Best Mattresses For Side Sleepers
• Best Mattresses for Back Sleepers
• Best Mattresses for Stomach Sleepers
• Best Mattresses for Combination Sleepers
• Best Mattresses For a Lightweight Person
• Best Mattresses For Heavy People
• Best Memory Foam Mattresses for Heavy People

Both pocketed coils and base foam offer excellent adaptable support. Side sleepers especially might want to opt for zoned support coils to get the right level of pressure relief in the right spots. See our guide on hybrid mattresses for side sleepers for more information.

And every sleeper should stay away from most open coil systems, as these sag and do not contour to each body’s unique shape.

Warranty and Trial Period

Casper offers a 10-year limited warranty and a 100-night sleep trial period for all their mattresses. While these sound good on paper, they’re considered industry-standard acceptable minimums for mattress-in-a-boxes. So they’re adequate, but you can do better.

Many mattress-in-a-box companies with mail order mattresses now go well above and beyond these accepted minimums. Some offer 20 and even 25-year warranties. And many also offer sleep trials for up to a whole year. A generous sleep trial period and (especially) a generous limited warranty are indicators that a manufacturer has faith in their product and has built it to stand the test of time.

So if a mattress comes with a limited warranty that lasts a couple of decades and doesn’t have a bunch of loopholes, that should be a big point in its favor. Typically, a company offers a long-lasting warranty when they’re confident they’re offering one of the most durable mattresses.

FAQs

What’s the best cooling Casper alternative?

The Nolah Evolution 15 is the best alternative to the Casper Mattress for hot sleepers. This cooling hybrid combines several different technologies that offer breathability and thermal conductivity. The heat escape gusset, the breathable cover, and the pocketed coils keep cool air flowing. Meanwhile, graphite infusions and a cooling Euro top draw heat away from your body.

Those who want a cooling all-foam Casper alternative should consider the GhostBed Luxe. This mattress combines a breathable cover and several proprietary technologies like the Ghost Ice layer and gel swirl memory foam to draw heat out of the mattress despite the lack of breathable coils in the support layer.

A more affordable cooling foam mattress is the Zoma Mattress, with a design that maximizes recovery while remaining budgt-friendly.

What’s the best Casper alternative for side sleepers?

The Vaya Mattress is the best Casper alternative for side sleepers. Its highly contouring foam offers ideal pressure relief for side sleepers. It will cushion your joints and relieve pressure points without losing buoyancy or letting you sink down into the bed. It also provides tons of comfort at an amazing price.

Another fantastic alternative to the Casper Mattress for side sleepers is the Helix Midnight Luxe. Its layers of memory foam and zoned support coils offer targeted pressure relief right where you need it. The Midnight Luxe also features cooling technologies to keep you from overheating.

How can I get a good deal on a Casper Mattress alternative?

There are lots of ways to get a good deal on a Casper alternative. One of the best ways is to avoid brick-and-mortar stores and order online. Mattress-in-a-box companies offer all the quality of brick-and-mortar stores without the additional overhead included in the price. Cutting out physical stores means the customer isn’t paying the seller’s light bill and salesforce’s salaries.

Another great way to get a deal on a Casper alternative is to hit the sales. Typically, sales run around long weekends and big celebrations like July 4th, Black Friday, and President’s Day. Sellers can slash prices sometimes in half during these sales, so always be on the lookout.

What is a good sleep trial period length for a Casper alternative?

The sleep trial period is an important part of the mattress buying experience. Many people think they can just sit down on a mattress in the store and let that be that. But mattresses have to go through a “break-in” period for you to know how they’re going to feel. This break-in period usually lasts around 90 days.

That means you need at least a 100-night sleep trial period. A 100-night sleep trial period allows you to break in the mattress and sleep on it a few nights afterward. A 100-night trial can ensure you know exactly what you’ll be sleeping on for the next decade or more.

What’s the best Casper alternative for sleepers with back pain?

The best alternative to Casper for back pain sufferers is the Zoma Mattress. This sports mattress was made for physically active individuals, but it’s also a fantastic mattress for back pain sufferers. It provides spine-aligning contouring and a medium to medium-firm feel to keep your body lifted onto the sleep surface.

For more suggestions, check out our best mattress for back pain guide.

Bottom Line

The Casper Mattress lineup is an excellent brand that offers lots of comfort technologies. However, if it’s not for you, for whatever reason, there are lots of amazing options out there that can serve as your best mattress and provide you with a good night’s sleep.